Which cities in the US had the highest murder rates per capita in 2024?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive Summary
The provided analyses offer conflicting lists of U.S. cities with the highest homicide rates in 2024: one set ranks St. Louis, Detroit, Baltimore, Memphis, and Chicago at the top, while another places Chicago, Memphis, Philadelphia, Los Angeles, and St. Louis as the leaders. Important federal reporting noted large national datasets for 2024 but explicit city-by-city per-capita rankings are absent or preliminary, creating room for divergent interpretations and media lists [1] [2] [3] [4]. Readers should treat any single published list as provisional until cross-checked with final FBI or council-style per-capita tabulations [4] [5].
1. Why the lists disagree and what that reveals about the data puzzle
Different analyses point to inconsistent city rank ordering because sources rely on varying methodologies, timeframes, and provisional datasets. One compilation asserts St. Louis led in 2024 with 48.6 homicides per 100,000 and Detroit and Baltimore following, citing a council-style study that reports city per-capita rates [2] [1]. Another source claims Chicago topped a different list alongside Memphis, Philadelphia, and Los Angeles, noting Chicago experienced declines entering 2024 yet still appearing high on some tallies [3]. The federal FBI release covers millions of offenses nationally for 2024 but explicitly lacks city-level per-capita breakdowns in the provided excerpts, which fuels divergent interpretations [4].
2. Which sources claim what — mapping the headline winners
The most specific per-capita claim in the provided material identifies St. Louis at 48.6, Detroit at 37, and Baltimore at 35.2 per 100,000, which matches a council-style dataset and an online compilation of top-30 cities [2] [1]. A different dataset or media synthesis places Chicago at the top of its ranking alongside Memphis, Philadelphia, and Los Angeles, despite noting Chicago’s homicide counts were falling in recent years and early 2024 [3]. Another FBI-analysis note flags Louisville as having higher per-capita killings than Chicago or Los Angeles in 2024, but that item did not supply a full ranked list or per-capita figures in the excerpt [3].
3. Federal data: large picture but limited city granularity
The FBI’s national reporting for 2024 comprises over 14 million reported offenses and preliminary quarterly snapshots that document trends such as a reported 22.7% decrease in murder through mid-2024 in the Quarterly Uniform Crime Report. However, the specific FBI texts cited here do not present a finalized, city-by-city per-capita homicide ranking in the provided passages, leaving private compilations and local reporting to fill the vacuum [4] [5]. That gap explains why independent lists, which may use local police tallies or different population denominators, produce different top-city rosters.
4. Timing and methodology matter — provisional vs. finalized counts
Some analyses use preliminary or partial-year data (for example, Q1–Q2 snapshots) while others use compiled annualized counts or council-style population adjustments; these choices shift rankings. The council-style number placing St. Louis at 48.6 per 100,000 is dated January 30, 2025, implying it drew on 2024 year-end tallies or reconciled datasets [2]. By contrast, a June 2024 compilation listing top-30 cities likely relied on earlier 2023–2024 reporting windows and media aggregation practices [1]. The FBI quarterly and annual releases are dated later and stress that their published city-level breakdowns are not fully captured in the cited excerpts [4] [5].
5. Points of agreement and where uncertainty concentrates
Across sources there is broad agreement that a set of Midwestern and East Coast cities — St. Louis, Detroit, Baltimore, Memphis, Chicago — frequently appear among the highest per-capita homicide rates for 2024, even when exact ordering varies [1] [2] [3]. The main uncertainties are the placement of cities like Philadelphia, Los Angeles, Louisville, and whether Chicago ranked first or lower. These discrepancies stem from differing use of provisional FBI snapshots, local police counts, population denominators, and whether counts are annualized or represent partial periods [3] [5].
6. What readers should demand before accepting any single ranking
Users should require explicit disclosure of the data source, the date range covered, the population denominator, and whether the figures are finalized or provisional. Given the cited FBI releases lack city-level per-capita detail in the provided excerpts, relying solely on aggregated media lists without such metadata risks misleading conclusions [4] [5]. Cross-checks with municipal police departments, council-style reconciled datasets, and final FBI tallies—when released with city-level breakdowns—are necessary to confirm a definitive 2024 ranking [2] [1].
7. Bottom line and next verification steps
The provisional evidence indicates St. Louis, Detroit, Baltimore, Memphis, and Chicago are commonly reported among the highest per-capita homicide cities for 2024, but alternative compilations list Chicago, Memphis, Philadelphia, Los Angeles, and St. Louis as top contenders, highlighting unresolved ranking differences [1] [2] [3]. To resolve the remaining ambiguities, consult final FBI city-level releases and reconciled municipal tallies, and demand transparent methodology notes on how per-capita rates were calculated and whether counts are finalized or preliminary [4] [5].