Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What was quarterly GDP growth under Biden compared to Trump and the 2010s average?
Executive summary
Quarterly and annual GDP performance under Presidents Biden and Trump varies across sources and time windows: FactCheck reports average annual real GDP growth of 2.5% under Biden with a 6.2% peak in 2021 (the pandemic rebound) and notes Trump’s growth peaked at about 3% in 2018 [1]. More recent commentary about the early months of Trump’s second term cites quarterly nowcasts and estimates—examples range from an Atlanta Fed–style nowcast putting a single-quarter estimate between about 2.7% and 4% [2] to outlets highlighting annualized gains near 3.8% for certain 2025 estimates [3]. Available sources do not provide a single, consolidated "quarterly GDP average by president" number; reporters and analysts use different measures and windows [1] [2] [3].
1. What FactCheck measured for Biden vs. Trump — a calm baseline
FactCheck’s roundup compares multi-year, calendar/annual changes: it lists Biden’s overall increase in real GDP averaging about 2.5% over his term with a 6.2% surge in 2021 as the economy rebounded from the 2020 pandemic contraction, and it notes that during Trump’s first term growth peaked at roughly 3% in 2018 [1]. This framing treats GDP as an annualized calendar series across presidencies and emphasizes that Biden’s large 2021 rebound skews multi-year averages [1].
2. Quarterly nowcasts and short windows produce different headlines
Journalists and partisan outlets frequently point to short-term, quarterly nowcasts to argue momentum for one president or another. For example, commentary praising early Trump administration strength cites an Atlanta Fed–style estimate projecting fourth-quarter GDP between about 2.7% and 4% [2]. Separately, pieces that tout a near‑4% annualized pace for a particular year cite different model estimates or provisional bureau releases [3]. Those snapshots can differ sharply from the multi-year averages FactCheck uses because they capture only brief stretches of growth [2] [3].
3. Why comparisons are tricky — methodology and timing matter
Comparing “quarterly GDP growth under Biden” to “quarterly GDP under Trump” depends on which quarters you pick, whether you annualize a single quarter, and whether you average quarters across a full term. FactCheck’s term-level view uses annual real GDP growth and highlights a large 2021 rebound after 2020’s collapse [1]. By contrast, media pieces invoking Atlanta or New York Fed nowcasts look at high-frequency, model-based estimates for recent quarters that can show stronger or weaker short-run growth [2]. Different time windows and models therefore produce competing impressions [1] [2].
4. Political framing in reporting — competing narratives exist
Conservative outlets credit tariff-driven import declines and other policies for brisk third- or fourth-quarter growth and cite high estimate figures like 3.8% annualized growth in 2025 [3] [4]. Mainstream outlets and fact-checkers emphasize the context: Biden’s 2021 spike was a post-recession rebound rather than steady expansion, and public perceptions of the economy did not always track headline GDP gains [1] [5]. Polling and analysis show partisanship shapes how growth is interpreted — Republicans may highlight short-term gains under Trump while Democrats stress recovery from the pandemic under Biden [1] [6].
5. What the sources agree on — and what they don’t
Sources agree that Biden oversaw a large rebound in 2021 (6.2% peak) and that Trump’s best calendar-year growth in his first term reached about 3% in 2018 [1]. Sources diverge, however, on whether recent quarters under Trump represent sustained outperformance: some outlets cite nowcasts and provisional numbers suggesting quarters or years near 3–3.8% [2] [3], while fact-checking coverage and broader trend analyses caution that single‑quarter spikes and tariff-induced import shifts can overstate durable domestic demand [1] [4].
6. What’s missing or uncertain in current reporting
Available sources do not provide a single standardized series of “average quarterly GDP growth by presidency” covering both Biden and Trump with identical methodology; instead, reporting mixes annual averages, term summaries, and short-term nowcasts [1] [2] [3]. If you want a precise, apples-to-apples number (for example, the average of all four quarters in each presidential year or the mean quarterly annualized growth across each term), that exact calculation is not included in the cited pieces and would require extracting Bureau of Economic Analysis quarterly releases or a consistent reconstruction from Fed nowcasts — steps not present in these sources [1] [2].
Bottom line: use the FactCheck term averages to understand the multi-year arc (Biden ~2.5% with a 6.2% 2021 peak; Trump peaked ~3% in 2018) and treat shorter-term, quarterly nowcasts and media estimates as snapshots that can diverge depending on models and timing [1] [2] [3].