Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How will the 2025 reclassification affect federal student aid eligibility and loan forgiveness?
Executive summary
The 2025 reclassification and related legislation (commonly discussed as the “One Big Beautiful Bill/OBBBA” and executive actions in 2025) change who can get federal aid and narrow the pathways to loan forgiveness; many changes take effect July 1, 2026, while some provisions and department rulemakings already affect 2025 aid and forgiveness processing (examples: Pell eligibility formula changes and PSLF rule changes) [1] [2]. Available reporting shows expanded Pell criteria via the new Student Aid Index (SAI) but also new limits that can render students ineligible when they receive other non‑Title IV grants; meanwhile PSLF and income‑driven forgiveness have been tightened and restructured with new regulatory guidance and litigation shaping tax treatment for cancelled debt through 2025 [3] [1] [2] [4].
1. What “reclassification” means for federal aid: the SAI replaces EFC and shifts Pell rules
The FAFSA overhaul introduced a Student Aid Index (SAI) that replaces the Expected Family Contribution and changes how Pell Grant eligibility is determined; the Department of Education and Federal Student Aid materials say the SAI is used by colleges to calculate eligibility and that Pell eligibility has been expanded for some students under the new formula [3] [5]. At the same time, the reconciliation law’s tweaks include a provision that can bar a student from receiving a Pell award if they receive non‑Title IV grant aid that, combined with other aid, equals or exceeds cost of attendance — a change likely to deny Pell to some otherwise‑eligible students [1].
2. Timing and who is affected: staged rollouts and grandfathering
Multiple sources stress that the major statutory changes tied to the reconciliation package generally phase in on and after July 1, 2026, while the 2024–25 FAFSA changes (including SAI) were already implemented for the 2024–25 award year and continue to affect reporting and processing [5] [6]. Colleges and states that rely on FAFSA data will need to adapt; institutions and students who enroll before specified cutoffs may be able to use earlier rules, but the handbook and agency guidance remain the authoritative implementation vehicles [5] [7] [6].
3. Net effect on aid amounts and eligibility: mixed winners and losers
Analysts and trade groups describe a mixed picture: the SAI’s ability to be negative may increase Pell access for some low‑income students, yet other statutory limits (including programmatic caps and new median‑cost limits being discussed by commentators) and the non‑Title IV grant exclusion could reduce access for others — for example, full‑ride scholarship recipients might lose Pell under the new exclusion rule [3] [1] [8]. Commentators also note proposals to cap aid to a program’s median cost or impose new borrowing caps for parents — proposals reported as part of 2025 discussions that would materially limit total aid available if enacted [8].
4. Loan forgiveness: PSLF and IDR under pressure and rulemaking
The Department of Education issued a final rule in 2025 to “restore” PSLF and to tighten the definition of qualifying public service employment; that rulemaking and related executive orders aim to exclude employers the department deems to engage in “substantially illegal activities,” which narrows who qualifies for forgiveness [2]. Simultaneously, the department’s rulemaking processes and the RISE committee work are reshaping income‑driven repayment (IDR) and other forgiveness rules; reporting says updated regulations will be published for comment and will change eligibility and counting of payments toward forgiveness [9] [10].
5. Tax treatment and litigation: temporary relief, uncertain future
Several outlets and advocacy groups report that debt discharged under IDR and certain other programs has been treated as tax‑exempt through the end of 2025, but that tax relief is temporary and set to expire unless extended by law or administrative action [4] [11]. Litigation and settlements (for example, with the American Federation of Teachers) have prompted the department to resume some forgiveness processing and to clarify that borrowers whose cancellations are processed in 2025 won’t owe federal income tax on that relief — but beyond 2025 the sources warn tax treatment could change [12] [13].
6. Practical implications for students and borrowers: what to watch and do
Students should track their award years (which rules apply to them), complete FAFSA/consent steps now because lack of consent blocks SAI calculation and eligibility determinations, and monitor school and state communications since institutional packaging may shift under new median‑cost or program caps [5] [8]. Borrowers seeking forgiveness should document qualifying employment, follow departmental guidance about PSLF and IDR enrollment, and watch for formal rule publications and public comment windows that will clarify implementation [10] [9].
Limitations and conflicts in reporting: official ED guidance and the 2025–26 FSA Handbook will be the final word on implementation, and available sources show disagreements about scope and timing (some say broad changes won’t apply until mid‑2026 while others describe immediate program changes or executive actions in 2025) — readers should prioritize ED notices and their school’s financial aid office for definitive answers [7] [6] [10].