Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How do licensing boards determine whether a degree is considered professional for practice?
Executive summary
Licensing boards typically judge whether a degree is “professional” by checking if it prepares graduates to begin practice in a regulated occupation, whether it goes beyond a bachelor’s-level skill set, and whether the profession generally requires state licensure — criteria the Department of Education and negotiating committees recently formalized in draft definitions (e.g., “signify students have the skills to begin practice,” require post‑baccalaureate coursework, and “generally require professional licensure”) [1] [2]. States and individual licensing boards, however, still control licensure rules and may add accreditation, coursework, clinical training, or supervised experience requirements — so the same degree can be treated differently across boards [3] [4].
1. What regulators say: the federal framing that drives debate
Federal rulemaking discussions led by the Department of Education and the RISE committee have proposed a working definition of “professional” degrees that emphasizes three elements: the program must (a) signify students can begin practice in a profession, (b) require skills beyond a bachelor’s degree, and (c) generally be tied to professional licensure and often to doctoral‑level or multi‑year post‑baccalaureate instruction [1] [2]. That framing matters because it’s being used to set federal loan caps and other federal policy — and the committee’s list and criteria have sparked pushback from fields that may be excluded [1] [5].
2. What state licensing boards actually do: local authority and nuance
Despite federal discussion, professional licensure itself is largely administered by state boards, which set the concrete educational and experience standards for entry. The U.S. Department of Education notes that licensure “is generally administered by a state‑level authority” and that requirements and reciprocity vary widely by profession and state [3]. State boards often require accredited degrees, specific coursework, supervised clinical hours, national exams, and verification of experience — and they may accept alternative education plus experience in lieu of an explicitly labeled “professional” degree [4] [6].
3. Accreditation, program length and clinical training: common practical tests
Boards and credentialing bodies frequently look for accreditation (for example, ABET for engineering) and for minimum program length or clinical components. For engineers, most states expect an ABET‑accredited bachelor’s or equivalent, and non‑accredited degrees may require extra years of verified experience [6] [7]. The RISE proposals similarly point to minimum years of postsecondary instruction (often six years total, including post‑baccalaureate study) as a marker of a professional program [1] [2].
4. Licensure vs. degree label: practice readiness matters more than the name
Multiple sources show that boards prioritize whether the curriculum “signifies completion of the academic requirements for beginning practice” over whether the diploma uses a particular title [2] [1]. That’s why debates arise when degrees like DPT, AuD, MPH, or RN aren’t explicitly listed in narrow federal lists: some stakeholders argue the program’s competencies and licensure pathway make them professional, while some federal drafts limit inclusion by degree type and duration [8] [5].
5. Where conflicts and confusion occur: federal lists vs. board discretion
Tension appears when federal policy (for student loan eligibility or reporting) uses a specific list or rigid criteria while licensing boards exercise state‑level discretion. News reporting shows organizations pushing back when fields such as nursing or public health aren’t named on an initial federal list, arguing that excluding them from the “professional” label will affect student loan limits and workforce pipelines — even though the Department of Education stresses the statutory definition has long required practice readiness and licensure connection [9] [5] [1].
6. Practical takeaway for students and educators
If you need to know whether a degree will qualify you for licensure in a given state, consult the specific state licensing board and professional accreditor: federal proposals set broad policy markers but do not replace state licensure rules. Institutions and students should check state laws and SARA/reciprocity policies when programs cross state lines, because states may require program‑level approvals, clinical authorization, or disclosure practices tied to licensure eligibility [4] [3].
Limitations: available sources document the Department of Education’s proposed criteria, state board control, and examples (engineering, nursing, public health debates), but they do not provide a single, universal checklist used by every licensing board — boards vary and often supplement degree requirements with licensure exams, supervised experience, or accreditation checks [1] [6] [3].