Professor Kelley Trump
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
A widely repeated anecdote holds that William T. Kelley, a longtime Wharton marketing professor, called Donald J. Trump “the dumbest goddamn student I ever had,” a claim traced almost entirely to Frank DiPrima, a friend of Kelley, and amplified by multiple outlets and social pages [1] [2] [3]. The available reporting shows consistent repetition of DiPrima’s account but no contemporaneous primary record from Kelley himself or official Wharton documentation that directly confirms Kelley uttered the phrase, so the claim is credible in provenance but not independently verifiable [2] [1].
1. How the quote entered the public record and why it stuck
The assertion that Kelley disparaged Trump comes from attorney Frank DiPrima, who said Kelley told him “100 times over three decades” that Trump was “the dumbest goddamn student I ever had,” and that recollection has been cited by Philadelphia Inquirer reporting and reprinted across outlets such as Study International, Poets&Quants and The List [1] [4] [3] [5]. Fact‑checking sites have traced the circulation and noted the remark has been posted repeatedly on social media and partisan pages, which helped it propagate beyond local reportage into national conversation [2].
2. What the primary sources do — and don’t — show
Kelley taught marketing at Wharton for 31 years and died in 2011 at age 94, facts established in the reporting that contextualize why DiPrima’s second‑hand recollection is the chief source available [1]. None of the provided sources produce an audio, contemporaneous note, classroom evaluation or a public statement from Kelley himself containing the line; the record in these stories relies on DiPrima’s memory and the repeated retelling of that memory by journalists and commentators [2] [3].
3. Independent verification and fact‑checkers’ stance
Independent fact‑checking coverage flagged the quotation as post‑humous and second‑hand, pointing out that it has been circulated without direct evidence from Kelley and that the strongest support is DiPrima’s long acquaintance with the professor [2]. Multiple culture and education pieces have repeated DiPrima’s claim while also noting the absence of formal academic records made public that would corroborate Kelley’s private assessments of Trump’s intellect or grades [4] [3] [5].
4. Why the anecdote matters beyond an insult
The remark has been picked up because it fits larger narratives about Trump’s academic performance, arrogance in class, and later public persona — threads explored by commentators who connect alumni anecdotes to Trump’s self‑promotion about Wharton and disputes over his academic record [3]. At the same time, the lack of transparent college records means the quote functions more as character testimony than as hard evidence of Trump’s scholastic standing [5].
5. Competing perspectives and potential biases
Reporting that relies on a friend’s recollection raises predictable credibility questions: DiPrima’s decades‑long friendship with Kelley is explicitly noted by sources, which strengthens why his account is taken seriously but also highlights its personal and unverifiable nature [2] [1]. Media outlets and partisan social pages that amplified the line may have had incentives to promote a succinct, damning soundbite about a polarizing public figure, a dynamic flagged by fact‑checkers and follow‑up stories [2] [4].
6. Bottom line assessment
The best available reporting establishes that Kelley’s purported insult is a sustained second‑hand recollection widely reported by reputable outlets, making it plausible as an authentic memory recounted by a longtime friend, but it is not corroborated by primary documentation from Kelley or Wharton and therefore should be treated as unattributed hearsay rather than an independently proven fact [1] [2] [3].