Fact check: Anthony Cumia on The View Fawning Over Dylan Mulvaney's Trans Nonsense

Executive Summary — Short Answer Up Front

The claim that “Anthony Cumia [was] on The View fawning over Dylan Mulvaney’s trans nonsense” is not supported by the supplied source material: outlets documenting Dylan Mulvaney’s actual appearances on The View and related coverage do not show Anthony Cumia appearing or praising her, while listings for The Anthony Cumia Show make no mention of a crossover or that he “fawned” on The View. The available materials instead describe Mulvaney’s May–September 2025 media appearances and the Anthony Cumia Show’s general programming, which do not corroborate the specific allegation ^{[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]}.

1. What the Original Claim Alleges — A Direct Reading That Demands Evidence

The original statement asserts a direct event: Anthony Cumia appeared on The View and openly fawned over Dylan Mulvaney, framing Mulvaney’s identity as “trans nonsense” and indicating an on-air exchange. Verifying that requires at minimum: a dated The View episode transcript or clip showing Cumia as a guest; corroborating coverage from independent outlets with timestamps; or episode listings linking Cumia to that specific broadcast. The provided reporting on Mulvaney’s actual The View appearances documents her participation and topics discussed but contains no record of Cumia guesting or effusive praise by him, leaving the claim unsubstantiated on its face ^{[1] [2]}.

2. What the Mulvaney–The View Coverage Actually Shows — Context and Dates

Multiple pieces in the supplied dataset establish that Dylan Mulvaney appeared on The View to discuss her memoir Paper Doll and experiences with anti-trans backlash tied to a Bud Light partnership, with coverage dated March and September 2025. Those items report substantive discussion of trans hate, the Bud Light boycott, and cultural fallout, and include comments from co-hosts like Whoopi Goldberg about women’s sports in the same episodes. None of these writeups, dated March 11 and March 13, 2025, and September 26, 2025, reference Anthony Cumia participating on the panel or offering praise during the episode ^{[1] [2] [3]}.

3. What The Anthony Cumia Show Records Reveal — No Evidence of The View Crossover

Records and episode listings for The Anthony Cumia Show on WABC Radio in October and June 2025 show the program’s schedule and past episode coverage but do not list a The View appearance or an on-air praise exchange involving Dylan Mulvaney. The show’s public descriptions emphasize discussion of politics, current events, and culture; the supplied entries from October 8 and 19, 2025, and June 1, 2025, present no episode summary indicating Cumia participated in The View broadcast, supporting the absence of evidence for the claim ^{[4] [5] [6]}.

4. Reconciling the Two Storylines — Where the Claim Likely Diverges from Fact

The materials create two separate, verifiable threads: (A) Mulvaney’s media appearances and her memoir promotion with discussion of the Bud Light backlash; and (B) Anthony Cumia’s radio show episode listings. There is no supplied link joining them into a single incident where Cumia appears on The View and openly fawns over Mulvaney. The discrepancy suggests the original claim conflates or fabricates a crossover event. Given both sets of sources are contemporaneous and topical, the absence of corroboration in either stream is significant and reduces the claim’s credibility ^{[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]}.

5. Assessing Potential Biases and Motives Behind the Claim

All source materials must be treated as biased: entertainment outlets covering Mulvaney may emphasize controversy or human-interest angles, while WABC Radio materials present programming information and could downplay controversies tied to hosts. The original claim’s language — labeling Mulvaney’s identity “nonsense” and portraying Cumia as fawning — signals an intent to provoke and delegitimize. That rhetorical framing can indicate an agenda to discredit trans people and to associate a conservative media figure with supposed liberal praise, but the supplied sources do not substantiate such a narrative ^{[1] [2] [4]}.

6. Missing Evidence That Would Change the Assessment

To overturn the current assessment and validate the original allegation, one would need verifiable primary evidence: a dated video clip or transcript from The View showing Anthony Cumia on the set consenting to or expressing praise for Dylan Mulvaney, an official guest list naming Cumia for that episode, or reliable reportage from multiple independent outlets documenting the appearance. None of those items appear in the provided analyses; therefore, the claim remains unproven based on the available material ^{[1] [3] [5]}.

7. Practical Guidance: How to Verify Similar Claims Quickly

When encountering similar assertions, check three things: ^[7] primary broadcast records or video clips from the show in question, ^[8] episode guides from the network or distributor, and ^[9] contemporaneous reporting from multiple outlets. In this instance, the supplied episode listings and press pieces fail to produce the necessary primary evidence tying Anthony Cumia to The View appearance with Dylan Mulvaney, so the responsible conclusion is that the claim is unsupported by the available evidence ^{[4] [5] [1]}.

8. Bottom Line — What Readers Should Take Away Right Now

Based on the materials provided, the allegation that Anthony Cumia appeared on The View “fawning over Dylan Mulvaney” cannot be substantiated. The record shows Dylan Mulvaney did appear on The View to discuss her memoir and backlash from a Bud Light partnership, and Anthony Cumia’s program listings show no corresponding crossover or episode describing such conduct. The most accurate description of the situation using the supplied evidence is: the claim is unverified and likely inaccurate absent additional, direct