Fact check: By giving Emelia Perez 13 nominations, the Academy awards have completely forfeited any semblance of authority on what constitutes a competent, let alone good film.

1. Summary of the results

The statement oversimplifies a complex situation surrounding "Emilia Pérez." While the film did receive 13 Oscar nominations, making it the most nominated non-English language film in Oscar history ^[1], its reception has been notably mixed. The film has received a 76% critic score but significantly lower audience scores, ranging from 33% to 19% on Rotten Tomatoes ^{[2] [3]}. It's worth noting that the film has been successful in other major awards, including record-setting nominations at the Golden Globes and BAFTAs ^[4].

2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints

Several crucial contextual elements are missing from the original statement:

• The film is a Spanish-language, French-made Netflix production directed by Jacques Audiard ^[1]
• It has achieved historic milestones, including nominations for the first trans actor ^[1]
• There is significant controversy surrounding:
• The film's portrayal of Mexican culture, with Mexican film critic Ricardo Gallegos Ramos stating it has "united Mexico" in disliking it ^[5]
• Lead actor Karla Sofía Gascón's controversial social media posts about Muslims, George Floyd, and diverse Oscar winners ^[6]
• LGBTQ+ representation, with GLAAD labeling it "Not Good Trans Representation" ^[7]

3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement

The original statement presents a one-sided view that ignores several key factors:

• Industry Recognition: While the statement dismisses the Academy's judgment, the film has received widespread industry recognition beyond just the Oscars ^[4]
• Complex Reception: Rather than being universally poor, the film has sparked nuanced debates about representation, authenticity, and cultural portrayal ^{[5] [7]}
• Broader Context: The nominations come during a challenging time for Hollywood, dealing with wildfires and industry disruption ^[1]

Who Benefits:

• Netflix benefits from the controversy and nominations as the film's distributor ^[1]
• The French film industry benefits from international recognition ^[1]
• Critics and cultural commentators benefit from the ongoing debates about representation and authenticity
• The Academy itself benefits from appearing progressive while generating discussion about their nominations