Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: Did Jimmy Kimmel's 2024 ratings surpass his 2015 numbers?
Executive Summary
Jimmy Kimmel’s routine 2024 ratings did not surpass his 2015 season averages: Nielsen and aggregated reporting show 2015 averaged roughly 2.4 million viewers, while typical post-2019 seasons and 2024/early-2025 quarters have been substantially lower, often under 2 million and sometimes near the 1.7–1.8 million range [1] [2]. Exceptional singular episodes in 2025 drew very large audiences (6.3 million), but those are outliers tied to newsworthy returns and are not evidence that 2024 overall exceeded 2015 levels [3] [4] [5].
1. What supporters claim and what critics highlight about the numbers
Supporters of the idea that Kimmel “surpassed” earlier highs point to headline-making, single-episode spikes in 2025 that hit 6.26–6.3 million viewers, described by ABC and some outlets as the highest regularly scheduled episode in over a decade and the biggest late-night share since 1992 [3] [6] [5]. These accounts emphasize raw total-viewer spikes and 18–49 demographic gains for specific return episodes, framing them as indicators of renewed reach. Critics counter that these are isolated events and that season- and quarter-level averages, which smooth episodic volatility, remain well below 2015 levels [1] [2].
2. The core empirical comparison: 2015 season vs. routine 2024 performance
Long-form Nielsen reporting and year-over-year summaries show 2015 averaged about 2.4 million viewers, a high-water mark for the show during that era, while more recent quarterly reporting places typical viewership far lower—roughly 1.7–1.8 million in Q2 2025 and similar ranges through 2024 [1] [2]. These multi-episode averages are the proper comparator for asking whether “2024 ratings surpassed 2015,” and by that metric the answer is no: routine 2024 episodes did not exceed the 2015 season average [1] [2].
3. Why single large episodes distort the perception of overall performance
Outlier episodes tied to special events, returns, or particularly newsworthy moments can produce multiples of the regular audience—the 6.3 million figure is described as more than triple the typical audience and came from a specific return episode, not from normal weeks [4] [5]. Media outlets and ABC promoted those peak numbers because they are newsworthy, but network and Nielsen practice distinguishes between single-episode peaks and season/quarter averages; the latter determine whether a year “surpassed” another year [3] [6].
4. Broader trends and demographic context that matter for the claim
Late-night viewership has shifted across platforms and audiences, with the 18–49 demo often emphasized by networks; press around 2024–2025 reports average adults 18–49 numbers in some recent quarters near 220,000, far below 2015-era totals, reflecting both audience fragmentation and streaming consumption [1]. Even when total viewers temporarily spike, the sustained demo performance and the season averages—key metrics for advertisers and network comparisons—remain the proper basis for cross-year claims, and those metrics show decline since 2015 [1] [2].
5. The balanced conclusion and important caveats for readers
The fact pattern is clear: routine 2024 ratings did not exceed 2015 averages, but the narrative is complicated by prominent single-episode spikes in 2025 that temporarily outdrew past peaks [1] [3] [5]. Readers should note that networks often publicize episodic highs for publicity value, and that Nielsen season/quarter averages are the accepted comparator for year-over-year performance. Therefore, claims that “2024 surpassed 2015” are misleading without specifying whether they reference a lone episode or the full-season averages [4] [2].
6. Sources, dates, and why they matter to this judgment
The assessment relies on Nielsen-based reporting and contemporaneous news coverage: pieces noting the 2.4 million 2015 benchmark and 1.7–1.8 million recent averages were published in September 2025 and directly address season/quarter trends [1] [2]. Coverage of the 6.26–6.3 million return episode was published late September 2025 and explicitly treats that figure as an episodic spike [3] [4] [5]. Readers should weigh dated averages vs. episodic headlines and treat single-episode high-water marks as exceptional, not representative of 2024’s overall standing versus 2015 [6] [7].