Jingle bells
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
“Jingle Bells” was written by James Lord Pierpont and first published in 1857 as “The One Horse Open Sleigh” (later reissued as “Jingle Bells”) — its earliest documented public performance appears on an 1857 playbill, not in a Thanksgiving service, and the song contains no original Christmas references [1] [2]. Scholars debate whether Pierpont composed it in Medford, Massachusetts, in 1850 or in 1857 and note the song’s complicated afterlife — popularized through minstrel shows and later embraced as a Christmas standard [3] [4] [5].
1. A simple origin story — and the documentary wrinkle
The basic fact is uncontested in most accounts: James Lord Pierpont wrote the tune we now call “Jingle Bells,” originally published as “The One Horse Open Sleigh” in 1857 and later reissued with the title “Jingle Bells” [1] [6]. Archival work by researcher Jillian Hamill uncovered a playbill in Harvard’s Houghton Library showing the song performed publicly in September 1857 — evidence that pushes back against widely repeated local lore that Pierpont debuted it at a Thanksgiving church service [2].
2. Thanksgiving vs. Christmas — how the myth spread
A persistent claim — that Pierpont wrote the song for a Thanksgiving service — dates at least to a syndicated Christmas quiz in the mid-1980s and resurfaces every year online [2]. NPR and regional public radio reporting emphasize that the Thanksgiving-origin stories tend to circulate in late November while the song’s identification as a Christmas carol spikes in December, and Hamill’s archival findings challenge the Thanksgiving-service narrative [7] [8] [9].
3. Where and when Pierpont actually wrote it: competing claims
Local tradition in Medford, Massachusetts, holds that Pierpont composed the song in 1850 after watching sleigh races on Salem Street and that a tavern piano supplied the tune’s first notes, a story memorialized by a Medford plaque [3]. Other sources, including archival material tied to performances in Boston, support a mid-1850s composition and 1857 publication — the record is unsettled and different institutions emphasize different pieces of the evidence [3] [5].
4. The minstrel-stage route and racial-history questions
Several recent accounts and historians document that the song reached public audiences via 19th‑century minstrel performers; at least one report cites a Boston performance in 1857 connected to blackface variety shows, and commentators note the broader cultural context of minstrel entertainment in the song’s popularization [4] [2]. Some writers and commentators draw links between the minstrel circuit and the song’s dissemination; others stop short of asserting direct lyrical intent, noting only the troubling medium through which it spread [4] [2].
5. Pierpont’s biography complicates the narrative
Biographical accounts paint Pierpont as a mobile, sometimes controversial figure: born in New England, later living in Savannah, with family and political divisions that have invited scrutiny of his later Confederate sympathies [10] [11] [6]. These facts do not change the tune’s melody or publication history, but they have shaped modern interest in re-examining the song’s cultural and ethical background [10] [11].
6. From sleighing song to global Christmas staple
Despite the absence of explicit Christmas references in the original lyrics, “Jingle Bells” transitioned into the holiday canon as publishers, performers and later recording artists repackaged it; by the late 19th and early 20th centuries it was widely recorded and became associated with winter festivities worldwide [1] [12]. Sources note iconic moments — including widespread recordings and novelty versions — that cemented its seasonal identity [1] [12].
7. What reliable sources agree on — and what they don’t
Documentary evidence supports an 1857 publication and early public performance; local origin legends (Medford, Thanksgiving service in Savannah) are longstanding but inconsistent with cited playbills and archival finds [2] [3]. Available sources do not mention definitive proof that Pierpont wrote the song specifically for Thanksgiving services; instead, archival playbills and sheet-music dedications point to theatrical and popular-music channels [2] [5].
8. How to interpret the song today
Journalistic and scholarly accounts advise holding two truths together: the tune’s ubiquity and cheer coexist with uncomfortable historical layers — minstrel-era dissemination and aspects of Pierpont’s biography that invite scrutiny [4] [10]. A robust public conversation acknowledges both the song’s musical impact and the contexts that shaped how it reached audiences [4] [2].