What is the most notorious catfish case in the US?

Checked on September 22, 2025
Disclaimer: Factually can make mistakes. Please verify important information or breaking news. Learn more.

This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.

Was this fact-check helpful?

1. Summary of the results

The most notorious catfish case in the US is a matter of debate, with various sources presenting different cases [1] [2] [3]. One notable case is the catfish murder-for-hire scheme in the US, where an Indiana man posed as a Kansas man and offered millions of dollars to Alaskan teens to murder a 19-year-old woman [1]. Another significant case is that of Alexander McCartney, who was given a life sentence for extreme online sexual abuse of children and the manslaughter of a 12-year-old girl in the US, creating fake personas to target around 3,500 victims [2]. Additionally, the documentary 'Unknown Number: The High School Catfish' covers the case of Lauryn Licari and her boyfriend Owen McKenny being harassed by an unknown number, later revealed to be Lauryn's mother, Kendra [3]. Key points to consider are the severity of the crimes, the number of victims, and the impact on the community. Other sources discuss catfish smuggling [4], invasive catfish in the Chesapeake Bay [5], and trade disputes over catfish imports [6], but these are not directly related to the most notorious catfish case in the US.

2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints

Some sources do not provide information about catfish cases in the US, instead discussing cases in the UK [7] or presenting cookie policy notices [8]. Alternative viewpoints include the issue of catfishing and its impact on victims, as highlighted by the story of Immy, a teenager who was catfished by a prolific sex offender [9]. Missing context includes the fact that some sources do not provide specific information about the most notorious catfish case in the US, instead discussing related topics such as catfish smuggling or trade disputes [4] [5] [6]. It is essential to consider the different types of catfish cases, including online harassment, murder-for-hire schemes, and smuggling, to determine the most notorious case.

3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement

The original statement asks for the most notorious catfish case in the US, but does not provide a clear definition of what constitutes a "catfish case". This lack of clarity may lead to confusion and potential misinformation, as different sources may interpret the term "catfish case" differently [7] [8] [1]. Bias may also be present, as some sources may focus on specific types of catfish cases, such as online harassment or murder-for-hire schemes, while others may discuss related topics like catfish smuggling or trade disputes [2] [9] [3] [4] [5] [6]. It is crucial to consider multiple sources and evaluate the credibility of each to provide an accurate answer to the original statement [7] [8] [1] [2] [9] [3] [4] [5] [6].

Want to dive deeper?
What was the outcome of the Manti Te'o catfish case?
How did the MTV show 'Catfish' help solve online deception cases?
What are the most common tactics used by catfish in online relationships?
Can catfish cases be prosecuted under US federal law?
What role do social media platforms play in preventing catfish scams?