Who actually wrote jingle bells and when was it first published?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
James Lord Pierpont is credited with writing the tune and lyrics that became “Jingle Bells,” first published in 1857 under the title “One Horse Open Sleigh” and republished under the name “Jingle Bells; or, The One Horse Open Sleigh” by Oliver Ditson & Co. in 1859 [1] [2]. Local claims differ about where and exactly when Pierpont wrote it—Medford, Massachusetts, and Savannah, Georgia both stake a claim—and scholars continue to debate the song’s original context and early performances [3] [4].
1. Authors and the core attribution: James Lord Pierpont wrote the song
Historical reference works and multiple contemporary outlets identify James Lord Pierpont as the composer and lyricist of the piece that public culture now knows as “Jingle Bells,” originally published as “One Horse Open Sleigh” in 1857 [1] [5]. Modern publishers and reprints of the song continue to credit Pierpont as the author [6] [7].
2. Publication timeline: 1857 first print, 1859 republishing under the familiar title
The song first appeared in print in 1857 with the title “One Horse Open Sleigh” [5]. The sheet music was republished in 1859 by Boston publisher Oliver Ditson and Company under the title “Jingle Bells; or, The One Horse Open Sleigh,” which helped cement the modern name in public circulation [2].
3. Disputed birthplace and composition date: Medford vs. Savannah
Local histories and journalistic accounts note disagreement about when and where Pierpont actually wrote the song. Medford, Massachusetts, places a plaque at Simpson Tavern claiming Pierpont wrote the tune there around 1850, while Savannah, Georgia—where Pierpont later lived and worked—also claims authorship ties and performance history; reporters and historians still debate evidence and dates [2] [3] [4]. Available sources do not settle which town definitively hosted the composition.
4. Original title and lyrical content: not always a Christmas carol
Pierpont’s original 1857 piece bore the title “One Horse Open Sleigh” and contained additional verses and a more ribald, secular narrative about a sleigh ride and courtship than the sanitized, single-verse Christmas standard now sung—scholars and popular histories emphasize that the song was not originally presented as a Christmas hymn [5] [8].
5. Early performance context and minstrel connections
Some accounts record that early performances were in popular entertainment formats of the time; one source says it was first performed in a minstrel hall, and that early stagings could include blackface performance conventions—details that complicate the song’s cultural legacy and how modern audiences should understand its origins [8]. Sources differ on how central minstrel performance was to the song’s initial spread.
6. How the song became the standard we know: republication and popular recordings
The 1859 Ditson republication under the “Jingle Bells” title helped popularize the refrain and the simplified chorus; later 20th‑century recordings—by Benny Goodman, Glenn Miller, Bing Crosby and others—cemented the tune as a holiday staple [2] [5]. The song even became a cultural milestone when astronauts aboard Gemini 6 played it in space in 1965 [2] [5].
7. Scholarly debate and modern reassessment
Recent journalism and scholarship revisit Pierpont’s biography—his later service with the Confederacy and the composition’s social context—leading to renewed discussion of whether and how to separate the song from its author’s politics and performance history [4] [3]. NPR and other outlets highlight that different conclusions follow depending on which archival dates and local narratives are prioritized [4].
8. What available sources do not mention or resolve
Available sources do not provide incontrovertible archival proof (for example, a dated manuscript in Pierpont’s hand with a verified location) that pins down the exact day and place of composition; they also do not agree on the degree to which minstrel performance was responsible for the song’s first exposure beyond a single report [8] [4]. Further archival research would be required to settle those points.
In short: authoritative published sources and reference works uniformly credit James Lord Pierpont with composing the song that was published as “One Horse Open Sleigh” in 1857 and republished as “Jingle Bells” in 1859 by Oliver Ditson & Co., but disputes about the precise place, date, early performance context and cultural implications persist in the record [1] [2] [8] [4].