Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: When it comes to wind power does the wind not blow in winter?
Executive Summary
Winter is not universally windless: multiple studies show substantial wind energy potential in winter months, though there are important regional and episodic exceptions where wind power falls well below typical levels. Recent research documents both winter peaks in mean wind speed and recurrent wind droughts and atmospheric conditions that can suppress wind production for extended periods [1] [2] [3].
1. What people are claiming — and what the core claim means for energy
The original statement — “When it comes to wind power does the wind not blow in winter?” — is an imprecise claim conflating average seasonal wind climatology with operational wind-power output. Several analyzed sources extract two distinct assertions: that winter has low wind potential, and that winter experiences episodes when wind generation collapses. Research shows these are different phenomena: mean winter wind speeds can be high in many regions, while intermittent wind droughts can still cause long-lasting low-output events [1] [2]. Distinguishing average seasonal behavior from episodic anomalies is essential for policy and grid planning.
2. Multiple studies show winter can be a strong season for wind energy
A 2023 analysis found winter and spring exhibit the highest potential wind-energy capacity, with average speeds around 6.7 m/s in study areas — directly contradicting an absolute “no wind in winter” claim [1]. Additional modeling and seasonal-prediction work demonstrates skillful forecasts and identifiable winter peak seasons across large domains, indicating that winter often supplies reliable seasonal wind resource for power systems [4]. These findings support the position that, on average, winter is not a season of absent wind but frequently a season of enhanced wind potential.
3. But winter can also feature pronounced low-wind episodes — the wind drought story
Global analyses identify wind droughts — prolonged periods of anomalously low wind speeds — that occur across various regions and are sometimes more frequent in cold seasons. Northwestern Europe, for example, has experienced prolonged low-wind events that materially reduce wind generation, and atmospheric blocking in winter can depress wind power anomalies by tens of percent [2] [3]. These studies show that even where mean winter wind is strong, episodic suppressions can compromise generation for days to weeks, posing challenges for short-term system adequacy.
4. Seasonality varies sharply by location — small spatial changes matter
Research into geographical variability demonstrates that nearby sites can have opposite seasonality: some locations are summer-dominant, others winter-dominant [5]. Global analyses also show the greatest intra-annual variability in monsoon-influenced regions, while temperate zones often peak in winter or spring [6]. This geographic heterogeneity means sweeping statements about “the wind in winter” are misleading; planners must use high-resolution, site-specific climatology to assess typical winter performance and risks [5] [6].
5. Operational problems in cold climates amplify winter challenges
Studies focused on cold regions emphasize that icing and turbine performance can limit winter output even when winds are present, adding an operational layer distinct from meteorological wind speed [7]. Offshore and cold-climate wind farms face icing-induced curtailments and maintenance issues that are seasonal. Combined with phenomena like atmospheric blocking, these operational constraints mean winter resource assessments need to include environmental and technical risk factors, not just raw wind speed statistics [7] [3].
6. What this means for energy systems: complementarity and forecasting matter
The literature shows two practical takeaways: first, wind often complements solar by peaking in different seasons and at different times of day, but complementarity is spatially variable and not guaranteed at fine scales [5]. Second, improving seasonal and sub-seasonal forecasting has demonstrable value: skillful seasonal predictions for peak energy seasons, including winter, can reduce exposure to wind droughts and improve dispatch decisions [4]. Energy planners should therefore combine diverse renewables, storage, interconnection, and improved forecasting to manage winter risk.
7. Uncertainties, potential agendas, and remaining research needs
The body of work contains methodological differences, regionally focused case studies, and modeling assumptions that produce varying conclusions; authors sometimes emphasize system risk to promote storage or grid investment, while others stress seasonal potential to support wind build-out [2] [1] [4]. Gaps remain in long-term trends of winter wind patterns under climate change and in quantifying how often low-wind episodes will coincide across continents. Policymakers should treat single-study claims cautiously and prioritize multi-model, multi-site analyses and operational trials.
8. Bottom line — a pragmatic synthesis for decision-makers
In short, the claim that “the wind does not blow in winter” is false as a general statement: many regions have strong winter wind potential, but important and sometimes prolonged low-wind events and operational constraints occur, particularly in certain regions and cold climates [1] [2] [7]. The appropriate response is not rejection of wind power but integrated planning: use local climatology, account for episodic wind drought risk, invest in forecasting and mitigation (icing, storage, interconnection), and combine wind with other resources to ensure winter reliability [4] [7].