Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How did consumer confidence and retail sales in 2025 compare to 2024?
Executive Summary
Consumer confidence showed a sharp decline early in 2025 while retail sales generally rose versus 2024, producing a mixed picture: confidence softened meaningfully in February 2025, while headline retail receipts and projections point to higher nominal sales in 2025 than 2024. Different data streams and forecasts diverge on momentum and real spending, reflecting timing, composition, and inflation effects [1] [2] [3] [4].
1. A sudden confidence setback that matters for sentiment and future spending
The most direct signal on sentiment is the 7.0‑point drop in the Consumer Confidence Index to 98.3 in February 2025, a pronounced month‑to‑month weakening that signals households were less upbeat about current conditions and the near‑term outlook [1]. That decline is a discrete, dated deterioration in confidence and is not presented as a full year‑over‑year comparison in the source; it is, however, large enough to presage softer discretionary spending if it persists. The confidence reading is a leading indicator for demand because consumers’ purchase plans and expectations about jobs and incomes typically inform goods and services outlays. This drop therefore raises a plausible downside risk to the trajectory of 2025 spending relative to 2024, especially if labor market and inflation worries deepen [1].
2. Retail sales: nominal growth and sectoral detail point upward versus 2024
Official retail trade reporting and projections show nominal retail sales in 2025 above 2024 levels, with August 2025 sales up 5.0% year‑over‑year and a three‑month window (June–August 2025) up 4.5% from a year earlier, indicating continued nominal expansion in receipts [2]. Separate tallies report a 0.6% month‑to‑month gain in August 2025 and an ex‑volatile‑sectors control rise of 0.7%, underscoring that multiple components of retail activity contributed to the uptick [5]. Macro projections from a retail‑statistics compilation place U.S. retail sales at $7.45 trillion in 2025, about 2.56% higher than 2024’s $7.265 trillion, reinforcing the conclusion that measured retail revenue is larger in 2025 than in 2024 [3].
3. Real spending and “softening” narratives: forecasts and nuance
Forecasts and real‑spending measures paint a more cautious picture: several analyses estimate real consumer spending growth slowing in 2025 to roughly 3.7% from 5.7% in 2024, driven by a cooling labor market, tariff‑induced price pressures, and policy uncertainty [4]. Real personal consumption expenditures are reported as slightly below their December 2024 level in one analysis, signaling that inflation and composition effects (durable goods pull‑forward) have materially affected real demand comparisons [6]. These accounts emphasize that nominal retail gains can coexist with weaker real consumption once price effects and category shifts are accounted for, and that headline retail sales growth does not automatically equal stronger purchasing power for households [4] [6].
4. Contradictions and convergence: why some indicators show resilience
Other data suggest consumers continued to spend in 2025 despite slowing momentum: discretionary spending was reported as up 2.6% month‑to‑date as of May 20, 2025, even while April retail sales decelerated to a 0.1% gain, and control categories contracted modestly [7]. This pattern indicates heterogeneous behavior—affluent households and certain service or experience categories supporting spending while other cohorts pull back. The coexistence of stronger nominal retail receipts and pockets of softening real activity reflects sectoral divergence and timing: durable goods spending that surged earlier can create a “payback” in 2025, and services‑heavy consumption patterns show different inflation pass‑through than goods [7] [6].
5. Reconciling the bottom line: what we can and cannot conclude from these sources
Putting the pieces together, the authoritative conclusion is that retail sales in nominal terms were higher in 2025 than in 2024, supported by monthly reports and projections [2] [3]. At the same time, consumer confidence weakened materially at least in early 2025, and several analyses warn that real spending growth slowed versus 2024 once inflation, composition, and payback effects are considered [1] [4] [6]. The set of sources therefore delivers a coherent duality: stronger nominal sales but weaker sentiment and mixed real‑demand momentum. Users should note that timing differences, sectoral composition, and inflation adjustments drive these contrasting signals [5] [7].
6. Competing agendas, data gaps, and what to watch next
The sources reflect different emphases—government retail reports and market summaries focus on nominal receipts and short‑run month‑over‑month beats, while banks and research groups stress real activity, forecasts, and downside risks—which can create narrative divergence [2] [4]. Key gaps remain: the confidence series cited is a snapshot (February 2025) without a full year‑over‑year profile, and some retail projections are model‑based rather than final measures [1] [3]. Watch monthly retail reports, inflation‑adjusted PCE updates, and subsequent consumer‑sentiment releases to determine whether the February confidence drop was transitory or the start of a broader 2025 slowdown that will erode nominal gains into weaker real consumption [1] [6].