Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: Can I deduct Social Security taxes from my 2026 tax return?
Executive Summary
Social Security payroll taxes (the FICA or self-employment tax that funds Social Security) are generally not deductible on an individual’s federal income tax return, and you cannot subtract Social Security tax withheld from wages as an itemized deduction for tax year 2026; if too much was withheld, you can claim a credit rather than a deduction [1]. Separately, the taxable portion of Social Security benefits depends on combined income rules and recent legislative changes created a temporary, age‑based deduction that can reduce or eliminate tax on benefits for eligible seniors for tax years 2025–2028, which will affect many 2026 filers [2] [3] [4]. This analysis compares those claims, explains the distinctions between payroll taxes and benefit taxation, and identifies who might see relief on the 2026 return.
1. Why you can’t deduct payroll Social Security taxes — the plain legal split that matters
The core tax distinction is between payroll taxes (FICA/self‑employment tax) and the taxation of Social Security benefits as income; the sources uniformly treat payroll taxes as not deductible on the federal income tax return for individuals. The longstanding rule reflected in guidance and taxpayer literature is that Social Security taxes withheld from pay are not an itemizable deduction; the proper remedy where an excess amount was withheld is a credit on the return, not an above‑the‑line or itemized deduction [1]. That rule persists in contemporary commentary and tax guidance and remains the decisive factor for most wage earners preparing a 2026 return: you do not treat withheld Social Security tax the way you treat deductible charitable gifts or mortgage interest. The practical consequence is that ordinary workers cannot reduce adjusted gross income by deducting payroll Social Security paid during the year.
2. How Social Security benefits themselves can become taxable — the classic “combined income” test
A second, separate calculation determines whether Social Security benefits are taxable: the IRS computes “combined income” (half of Social Security benefits plus other income) and compares it to base amounts that vary by filing status, and only some portion of benefits becomes taxable if thresholds are exceeded [2]. This is not a deduction for payroll taxes but an inclusion rule that can put a share of benefits on line 6b of Form 1040. Analysts and tax preparer guides reiterate the same arithmetic and thresholds: benefits remain potentially taxable depending on total income levels. For a 2026 return, taxpayers who receive Social Security benefits must still apply this combined income test when preparing federal returns, unless they qualify for any temporary legislative relief that modifies taxable income treatment for older filers.
3. New 2025–2028 senior deduction changes — who gets relief on 2026 returns
Recent legislative changes introduced a temporary deduction targeted at older taxpayers for tax years 2025 through 2028 that can materially reduce or eliminate federal tax on Social Security benefits for eligible seniors and thus influence 2026 liability [4] [5]. Coverage and phase‑outs are tied to adjusted gross income limits and age-based eligibility — often referenced as an additional deduction (reported in commentary as $6,000 for those 65 and older in 2025–2028) — and tax authorities and commentators have flagged this as a major reason millions of older Americans could face lower or no federal tax on benefits during these years [3] [6] [7]. The practical effect is not a change to the non-deductibility of payroll taxes but a change in how much of Social Security benefit income is included in taxable income for eligible seniors when filing their 2026 return.
4. Where confusion arises — credits, deductions, and what each fixes
Confusion stems from conflating three different tax mechanics: payroll tax withholding, taxable benefits, and special deductions or credits. The sources clarify that an overpayment of payroll Social Security tax results in a credit — correcting payroll tax excesses — rather than an income tax deduction [1]. By contrast, adjustments introduced by recent legislation create a deduction that directly affects taxable income for seniors, thereby reducing the income portion of Social Security benefits that would otherwise be taxed [5] [4]. Tax preparers must therefore separate the payroll tax ledger from the income tax return computation: one is addressed through payroll tax credits or self‑employment tax adjustments, the other via the combined income test and any available age‑based deduction on the Form 1040 for the 2026 tax year.
5. Practical takeaway for 2026 filers — steps to take when preparing your return
For most taxpayers preparing a 2026 return, the actionable advice from the sources is clear: do not look for a line to deduct Social Security payroll taxes on Form 1040 because that deduction does not exist; instead, verify whether any overwithholding should be claimed as a payroll tax credit [1]. If you are age‑eligible or have adjusted gross income near the legislative thresholds, assess whether the temporary senior deduction applies to reduce taxable Social Security benefits for 2026 — that deduction is what will most likely change your tax on Social Security income, not a payroll tax deduction [4] [3]. Taxpayers should consult updated IRS instructions and qualified tax preparers because implementation details and phase‑out calculations for the temporary deduction will determine final liability and any refund or credit on the 2026 return [5] [8].