Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What share of total federal outlays was defense discretionary spending in 2020?
Executive Summary
In fiscal year 2020, defense discretionary spending represented roughly 10.8% of total federal outlays when measured as the $714 billion listed for defense discretionary outlays against $6.6 trillion in total federal outlays; this is the central numeric claim in the CBO-infographic reporting for FY2020. Other presentations frame the same $714 billion as about 44.6% of total discretionary spending (the narrower discretionary slice of the budget), and alternative tallies cite higher defense totals around $778 billion depending on the accounting choices used for defense-related items. These differences reflect two distinct accounting choices—comparing defense to total outlays versus comparing defense to discretionary spending—and both are circulating in official and secondary summaries of the 2020 budget [1] [2] [3].
1. Why two different percentages are being reported — a numbers clash that matters
Analysts and graphics cite $714 billion as the CBO’s figure for defense discretionary obligations in FY2020 and simultaneously report $6.6 trillion as total federal outlays, producing the 10.8% share widely presented for defense against the entire federal budget. That same defense figure appears in other summaries where the denominator is not total outlays but total discretionary spending of $1.6 trillion, yielding the much larger ~44.6% share of discretionary funds devoted to defense. The divergence is not a numerical error but a choice of framing: quoting defense as a share of total federal spending highlights its share of all federal priorities, while using the discretionary-only denominator emphasizes how large a slice defense takes out of annually appropriated funds [1] [2].
2. Conflicting defense totals: $714 billion versus $778 billion—and why it shows up
Beyond denominator selection, sources also report differing numerators for “defense spending.” The CBO-based infographic and a discretionary-spending graphic use $714 billion, while other compilations and military budget summaries list defense-related expenditures near $778.4 billion for 2020. These differences arise from scope and classification—whether the measure includes overseas contingency operations, certain defense-related retirement and veterans programs, or military-related portions of other agencies. The higher figure typically reflects a broader, more inclusive measure of national security spending, while the $714 billion figure corresponds to the narrower category labeled “defense discretionary” in CBO graphics [1] [3].
3. What each framing emphasizes and what it omits—policy implications
Presenting defense as ~10.8% of total outlays emphasizes that most federal spending goes to non-defense categories such as Social Security, Medicare, Medicaid, and interest on the debt; this framing can be used to argue that defense is a sizeable but not dominant portion of total federal activity. Framing defense as ~44.6% of discretionary spending highlights how much annual appropriations are consumed by defense relative to other programs that depend on Congress’s yearly decisions. Both framings are factual but highlight different policy levers and trade-offs; choosing one over the other often aligns with advocacy goals—defense proponents may prefer the total-outlays framing, while critics focusing on domestic discretionary priorities may emphasize the discretionary-share framing [2] [1].
4. Source reliability and provenance—what the supplied documents actually say
The claims in circulation stem from government infographics and budget documents: a CBO-style infographic lists $714 billion and $6.6 trillion (yielding 10.8%), while another infographic focused on discretionary budgets lists $714 billion within a $1.6 trillion discretionary total (yielding ~44.6%). Some military-budget overviews report a defense budget near $778.4 billion, representing broader measures of military-related spending. The supplied documents vary in publication dates (2021 and 2023 for the CBO-style materials) and differ in the labeling and classification of spending categories, which explains the coexistence of multiple, internally consistent but different headline percentages [1] [2] [3] [4].
5. Bottom line for readers and data users—choose the denominator intentionally
If you want a single, defensible answer: when using the CBO-style totals provided, defense discretionary was about 10.8% of total federal outlays in 2020; when comparing defense to only discretionary spending, the share is roughly 44.6%. Both are accurate given their respective definitions, and the larger apparent disagreement is a matter of classification and framing, not arithmetic error. Users should state the numerator and denominator explicitly when quoting these percentages, because advocacy and policy debates routinely exploit the choice of denominator to support contrasting policy narratives [1] [2] [3].