How do Social Security benefits (taxable and non-taxable) affect MAGI in 2026?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Social Security benefits — whether the monthly checks are taxable for federal income tax purposes or not — can still affect a household’s Modified Adjusted Gross Income (MAGI) in 2026 because MAGI is used for program eligibility and Medicare means-testing and explicitly adds back certain untaxed Social Security receipts (HealthCare.gov [1]; Georgetown CCF [2]1). Recent 2026 policy changes (a new senior deduction and shifts in state taxation) make the distinction between “taxable” on a tax return and “counted” for MAGI especially important for retirement planning (AARP [2]; Money p1_s4).
1. What MAGI means in 2026 and which Social Security payments are included
For many federal programs MAGI equals AGI plus specified add‑backs and, importantly, includes non‑taxable Social Security benefits along with untaxed foreign income and tax‑exempt interest, so even Social Security dollars that don’t show up as taxable on a Form 1040 can raise MAGI for eligibility and premium purposes (HealthCare.gov [1]; Georgetown CCF [2]1). SSI is an exception: Supplemental Security Income is not counted toward MAGI (Georgetown CCF [2]1). Some advisers and niche guides also note that certain untaxed SSDI or other Social Security receipts are explicitly added back when calculating MAGI for specific deductions and credits (TaxesForExpats [2]3).
2. How “taxable Social Security” on a federal return differs from MAGI treatment
Whether Social Security is taxable for federal income tax owed depends on the traditional “combined income” formulas used on tax returns (half of benefits plus MAGI compared to thresholds), so taxable amount and MAGI are related but not identical rules; federal taxability is determined by combined income formulas while MAGI for program rules adds back non‑taxable Social Security in full in many contexts (MoneyMatters / Busey [3]; Thrivent [2]5). That distinction matters because a retiree could pay no federal income tax on benefits yet still have MAGI high enough to affect Marketplace credits, Medicaid eligibility, Medicare IRMAA, or other means‑tested programs (Georgetown CCF [4]; HealthCare.gov [2]4).
3. MAGI and Medicare premiums (IRMAA): the practical consequences
Medicare’s income‑related monthly adjustment amount (IRMAA) and Part B/Part D surcharges use MAGI from two years prior, meaning 2024 MAGI determines 2026 surcharges; non‑taxable Social Security counted in MAGI can push beneficiaries into higher IRMAA brackets and trigger larger premiums even if those benefits weren’t taxed on the return (MedicareResources [5]; PrepareForMedicare p1_s8). The SSA and CMS use IRS returns to compute MAGI for IRMAA and provide appeals for life events that reduce income, so retirees hit by one‑time spikes (Roth conversions, asset sales) should note the two‑year lookback (SSA [6]; PrepareForMedicare p1_s8).
4. The 2026 “senior” deduction, thresholds and interaction with MAGI
A new deduction for taxpayers 65+ that can reduce taxable income by up to $6,000 in 2026 may lower a filer’s AGI and therefore MAGI for many purposes, potentially reducing taxes on benefits and lowering exposure to IRMAA or Marketplace phaseouts; eligibility phases in and out by MAGI (e.g., full credit under $75k single/$150k joint, phased and eliminated at higher bands), so its value depends on which income measure and program rules apply (AARP [2]; Money [7]; FinanceBuzz [2]0). However, because HealthCare.gov and some program MAGI definitions explicitly add back non‑taxable Social Security, the deduction’s effect may not fully neutralize the MAGI impact of untaxed benefits for every program (HealthCare.gov [2]4).
5. State tax changes and planning implications
States are diverging: some (like West Virginia) are phasing out taxation of Social Security which changes state taxable income but does not necessarily change federal MAGI used for Medicare or Marketplace calculations; retirees must watch both federal rules and evolving state laws when projecting MAGI and premium outcomes (CNBC p1_s3). Financial planning moves — timing IRA withdrawals, Roth conversions, charitable QCDs — remain the usual levers to manage AGI/MAGI exposure, but the two‑year IRMAA lookback and the fact that non‑taxable Social Security often gets counted into MAGI means tactical timing matters (Thrivent [8]; PrepareForMedicare p1_s8).
6. Bottom line and limits of available reporting
Bottom line: non‑taxable Social Security generally counts toward MAGI for Marketplace/Medicaid/Medicare IRMAA and can therefore raise premiums or deny credits even if those benefits aren’t taxed on a federal return; taxable Social Security affects AGI and thus MAGI through standard tax rules and the new 2026 senior deduction can lower AGI for eligible filers and mitigate some effects (HealthCare.gov [1]; AARP [2]; Busey [2]2). Reporting reviewed here documents these mechanisms but does not provide exhaustive, individualized tax calculations — specific outcomes depend on filing status, other income, state law and whether legislators change provisions still under consideration (MercerAdvisors p1_s7).