Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How does Pentagon base budget (PB) compare to total federal outlays each year 2020–2024?
Executive Summary
The Pentagon’s base budget from 2020–2024 represented a consistent and sizable share of U.S. federal outlays, rising in nominal dollars from roughly the low $700 billions to the low $800 billions and accounting for roughly 10–14 percent of total federal outlays across those years depending on the year and source. Reconciling datasets shows headline defense totals differ by method (Pentagon “base” budget vs. broader military spending, vs. supplemental/OCO and other agencies), so year-to-year percentage swings reflect both budgetary definitions and changing total federal outlays, not only changes in defense appropriations [1] [2] [3].
1. What the original claims said — Big statements that need parsing
The analyses claim the Pentagon base budget is a large portion of federal outlays and point to increases in nominal defense dollars and multi-year totals tied to wars and contracting. Key claims include that the Pentagon base budget rose from about $721.5 billion in 2020 to roughly $842 billion in 2024, and that defense constituted about 11–13 percent of federal outlays in recent years, with one source citing 13.3 percent in 2023 [1] [2]. Other claims expand the picture by adding military spending outside the Pentagon and long-run war costs, noting totals of hundreds of billions annually and multi-trillion cumulative obligations; these broadened figures are not the same as the Pentagon base budget but often get conflated with it [4] [5].
2. Which numbers are comparable — Definitions that change the result
Comparisons hinge on defining “Pentagon base budget” versus “total military spending” and which measure of federal spending is used (current-year outlays vs. unified federal outlays). The Department of Defense base budget figures reported—roughly $720–905 billion depending on year and inclusion of supplemental OCO—are the Pentagon’s core appropriations, while other analyses add DoD-related and non-DoD military spending to reach higher totals near $900–1,000 billion [1] [5]. Total federal outlays fluctuated from about $6.4–7.05 trillion in recent years; so the base budget’s share will vary depending on the denominator and whether figures are presented as budget authority, obligations, or outlays [1] [3].
3. Year-by-year picture — How the percentages shift, and why
Calculated from the provided materials, 2020 shows the Pentagon base near $721.5 billion against approximately $6.6 trillion in federal outlays, yielding about 10–11 percent; 2021 held near 11 percent; 2023 defense outlays were reported near $820.3 billion at ~13.3 percent of the federal budget; and 2024 base budgets cited around $841.4–842 billion, producing roughly 12–13 percent of total outlays depending on which total outlay figure is used [1] [2] [3]. Those percentage swings are driven partly by changes in total federal outlays (e.g., pandemic-era spending, economic cycles) and partly by increases or supplemental additions to defense funding; different sources also mix base, OCO, and broader national-security-related spending [5] [6].
4. Points of disagreement and why analysts diverge
Differences among sources arise from three technical choices: whether to include Overseas Contingency Operations (OCO) and other supplemental war spending, whether one counts non-DoD military spending (State Dept. security assistance, DOE naval reactors, VA war-related obligations), and whether analysts compare to budget authority, obligations, or outlays for the federal government. Advocates stressing larger military totals typically include classified/contract obligations and OCO; critics who emphasize the Pentagon’s relative share focus on the core base budget and unified outlays that include massive nondefense spending like Social Security and Medicare. These definitional choices produce materially different headline percentages even when the underlying dollar values are similar [5] [3].
5. What this means for readers — Context that changes interpretation
The take-away is that the Pentagon’s base budget is substantial and has grown in nominal terms, but its share of federal outlays is sensitive to measurement choices and to fluctuations in the broader federal budget. For policy debates or comparisons, it is essential to state whether figures represent the DoD base budget only, total national defense-related spending, or unified federal outlays, since conflating these leads to misleading claims about increases or cuts. The cited sources illustrate that 2019–2024 budget trends reflect both rising defense commitments and shifting fiscal baselines, and careful comparison requires aligning definitions before drawing conclusions [1] [4] [6].