What qualifies as a ‘qualified’ appraiser for valuing inherited precious metals?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
A “qualified” appraiser for valuing inherited precious metals is not merely any jeweler or coin dealer but an individual who meets IRS criteria: formal appraisal credentials or equivalent education and experience, regular compensated appraisal practice, demonstrable expertise in the type of property being valued, adherence to professional appraisal standards (like USPAP), and no recent prohibition from practicing before the IRS [1] [2] [3]. These rules are framed in IRS regulations and guidance created to ensure independence, competence, and defensible documentation when values affect tax reporting or estate administration [3] [4].
1. Legal baseline: the IRS definition that governs most disputes
The baseline for “qualified appraiser” comes from IRS regulations and guidance: an appraiser must hold an appraisal designation from a recognized professional organization or otherwise meet IRS education and experience thresholds, perform appraisals regularly for compensation, and show verifiable expertise in valuing the specific property type — in this context, precious metals — while not being barred from practice before the IRS for three years prior [1] [3] [2].
2. Credentials and continuing education: what credentials actually mean in practice
Credentials cited by the IRS typically include designations from appraisal groups (e.g., ASA, MAI, ISA) or equivalent coursework and documented experience; several industry guides emphasize that appraisers should complete coursework in valuing the property type and carry at least two years of regular appraisal experience for that property class [2] [5] [1].
3. Standards and independence: USPAP, fee structure, and objectivity
A qualified appraiser must follow generally accepted appraisal standards — practically, the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice (USPAP) — and must be paid on an hourly or flat-fee basis rather than a percentage of value to preserve objectivity; the IRS and professional guides stress these points to reduce conflicts that could skew valuations used for taxes or estates [2] [3].
4. Property-specific expertise: why “precious metals” needs a sub-specialist
The IRS requires demonstrable verifiable experience in valuing the specific type of property being appraised, which for inherited precious metals often means knowledge of bullion vs. numismatic coins vs. jewelry, spot/premium pricing dynamics, purity testing, and market channels — areas where generic appraisers or retail dealers may lack necessary documentation practices or comparables unless they can prove relevant expertise [1] [6] [7].
5. Documentation and report requirements: the appraisal as a legal document
A qualified appraisal must produce a written appraisal document meeting IRS content rules (description sufficient to identify the property, methodology, qualifications of the appraiser, and required signatures and dates); for tax-related filings, specific forms and attachments (for example, Form 8283 and appraisal summaries in donor situations) are cited in guidance and regulations [3] [8] [9] [10].
6. Enforcement and gray areas: what the guidance does not fully answer
Although IRS rules are explicit about who qualifies and what a qualified appraisal must contain, transitional guidance and later rule-making have left some questions for interpretation — for instance how a non‑designated but well‑experienced appraiser qualifies under newer standards or how state licensing interacts with federal criteria — meaning taxpayers and estates often rely on professional organizations’ norms and IRS Notices for practical clarity [1] [4].
7. Practical warning: conflicts of interest and commercial incentives
Readers should note a practical tension: firms that both appraise and buy precious metals (dealers/brokers) may offer convenience but raise conflict-of-interest concerns; the IRS standards and industry best practices push for independent, USPAP‑compliant appraisals paid by flat fee or hourly rate to avoid incentivized inflation or suppression of values [2] [6].
8. Bottom line for inherited precious metals: who to hire and why
For inherited precious metals that will affect estate tax reporting, basis determination, or later capital gains, a qualified appraiser is someone who can document formal appraisal credentials or demonstrable equivalent experience specific to metals, follows USPAP, provides a complete IRS‑compliant written appraisal, is paid independently of sale proceeds, and has no recent prohibition from practicing before the IRS — all criteria derived from IRS regs and contemporary guidance [1] [3] [2] [10]. Sources consulted establish the legal test but do not supply a single approved list of practitioners; locating an appraiser who meets these benchmarks and documents them is essential for defensible valuations [11] [6].