Will New York tax social security checks?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
New York State does not tax Social Security benefits for residents: Social Security (including Tier 1 railroad and disability benefits) that appear on federal adjusted gross income can be subtracted when computing New York adjusted gross income, and residents claim that subtraction on the resident return (IT‑201) [1] [2]. That state exemption is independent of whether some of those benefits are taxable at the federal level, where provisional‑income rules can make up to 85% of benefits federally taxable [3] [4].
1. New York’s rule: a state subtraction, not a state tax on benefits
New York accomplishes the exemption through a subtraction modification: Social Security equivalent Tier‑1 railroad retirement benefits and Social Security payments that are included in federal adjusted gross income may be subtracted when computing New York adjusted gross income, and residents file that subtraction on line 27 of Form IT‑201 (New York State Department of Taxation and Finance) [1]. Multiple tax guides and financial publishers confirm New York’s position: the state “does not tax Social Security benefits” (Edelman/Financial Engines, Kiplinger, SmartAsset) [5] [6] [7].
2. Federal taxation still matters — the two different systems
The New York exemption does not change federal rules: depending on combined or “provisional” income, up to 50% or 85% of Social Security benefits can be included in federal taxable income and therefore appear on federal AGI (and then be subtracted for New York purposes) (AARP explanation of provisional income and federal thresholds; JustAnswer summary of federal rules) [3] [4]. That means a retiree might owe federal income tax on a portion of benefits while owing no New York state tax on those same checks [3].
3. Scope: this includes SSD and Tier 1 railroad benefits, and applies to residents
Guidance and practitioner summaries explicitly extend the state exemption to Social Security Disability benefits and Tier 1 railroad retirement equivalents; New York’s subtraction applies to Social Security benefits reported in federal AGI, which includes SSD when it appears on federal returns (LegalClarity; FBRLaw summary) [2] [8]. The Department of Taxation language and the IT‑201 instruction apply to residents filing the resident return; nonresident rules or multi‑state situations are governed by separate residency and allocation rules not fully covered in the cited materials [1].
4. Retirement income beyond Social Security can still be taxable
While Social Security is exempt, New York taxes other retirement income differently: distributions from private pensions or retirement accounts may be partially taxable but New York offers a subtraction (up to $20,000 per person) for certain retirement plan distributions for those 59½ and older, which reduces taxable state income (Edelman/Financial Engines; SmartAsset) [5] [7]. In other words, Social Security itself is fully exempt at the state level, but other retirement sources can produce state tax liability unless reduced by available subtractions or credits [5] [7].
5. Practical takeaways and limits of available reporting
For a straightforward answer: New York will not tax Social Security checks that fall under the Social Security/ Tier‑1 railroad categories for residents — the state removes those amounts from New York AGI [1] [2]. Reporting reviewed here is explicit about residents and the subtraction mechanism; it does not provide detailed scenarios for nonresidents, for complicated multi‑state income allocations, or for the interaction of temporary federal tax changes noted by the State Comptroller, so those edge cases require looking at New York Tax Department instructions or professional advice beyond these sources [9] [1].