Will enhanced ACA subsidies expire or change in 2026 and how would that affect premiums?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
The enhanced ACA premium tax credits created by pandemic-era laws are scheduled to expire at the end of 2025 unless Congress acts, which would revert subsidies to the original 100–400% of FPL structure and sharply raise what most marketplace enrollees pay in 2026; KFF estimates average out-of-pocket premium payments would more than double — rising 114% from $888 to $1,904 — and insurers proposed roughly 26% gross premium increases even before subsidy changes are applied [1] [2]. Lawmakers failed in recent Senate votes to pass competing extension plans, making higher 2026 costs for millions the default under current law [3] [4].
1. The cliff date: what legally happens Jan. 1, 2026
Under current law the temporary, enhanced premium tax credits — expanded by the American Rescue Plan and extended by later action through 2025 — lapse automatically at the end of 2025 unless Congress enacts new legislation. That reversion restores the older subsidy formula (payments capped by fixed percentages of income and a 100–400% FPL eligibility band) and removes pandemic-era generosity that broadened eligibility and tightened income caps [5] [6].
2. How big the sticker shock could be
Independent analyses converge on large increases for enrollees: KFF projects average premium payments after subsidies would rise 114% (about $1,016 more per year, from $888 to $1,904) if the enhancements expire [1] [7]. Insurers’ 2026 rate filings also already reflect market turmoil: proposed gross premiums are up roughly 20–26% on average for 2026 before counting the subsidy rollback, and insurers say they factored an additional roughly 4 percentage points into rates because they expect healthier people to leave if subsidies weaken [8] [2] [9].
3. Who is most exposed — and who keeps some help
Low-income enrollees below certain thresholds will still qualify for non-enhanced premium tax credits and, in many states, zero-premium bronze options remain possible; but many middle-income households (including those above 400% FPL who benefited from the enhancements) will lose help and face much higher share-of-income requirements — for example, required premium contributions could rise from about 4.56% of income if enhancements were extended to about 8.87% if they expire, per CBPP estimates [10] [11]. Multiple analyses also warn that millions could drop coverage: Urban Institute, CBO, and other trackers estimate millions could lose marketplace coverage or become uninsured if credits lapse [12] [13].
4. Market ripple effects: insurer behavior and state variation
Insurers set 2026 rates anticipating both rising costs (hospital prices, new drug spending) and policy uncertainty. Filings in some states attribute an extra 4 percentage points of requested increases to the expected subsidy expiration [9]. State-level factors matter: states with reinsurance, Medicaid expansion, or state-funded subsidies will see smaller net harms; other states face more severe premium shocks and enrollment losses [8] [14].
5. The politics and legislative window now
Congress debated and held votes on rival measures — Democrats sought a multi‑year extension while some Republicans proposed alternative offsets like HSA payments or other structural changes — but recent Senate votes failed to advance either side, leaving the end‑of‑year lapse likely absent sudden action [15] [16] [3]. Proposals in the House and bipartisan petitions existed to force votes, but as of the recent floor activity no consensus emerged [16] [15].
6. Consumer choices and practical short-term impacts
With premiums posted and open enrollment underway, consumers are already responding: early state enrollment snapshots show increases in people switching to cheaper plans or pausing enrollment, and state marketplaces warn that many will face drastic out-of-pocket jumps or move from low-deductible silver plans to high-deductible bronze plans [17] [18]. Analysts emphasize timing: extending subsidies earlier would have lowered insurer rate requests for 2026, while last‑minute fixes would be harder to untangle into already‑set premiums and IT systems [14] [2].
7. Limitations, competing views, and what reporting leaves out
Analysts differ on exact enrollment and uninsured estimates — ranges run from several million to as many as roughly 7 million losing ACA coverage depending on modeling choices — and projected dollar impacts vary by age, state, plan choice, and assumptions about behavior [12] [1]. Available sources do not mention specific legislative text that would both extend enhancements and fully neutralize insurer rate changes for 2026; they instead report competing bills and budget estimates without a final compromise [16] [5]. Finally, some Republican proposals would replace enhanced credits with HSA deposits or other offsets; proponents frame that as consumer control, critics call it inadequate to blunt premium hikes [19] [20].
Bottom line: unless Congress enacts a timely extension or different compensation, current law will cause the enhanced ACA subsidies to expire after 2025 and drive large increases in what many marketplace enrollees pay in 2026, with outsized effects for middle‑income households and measurable disruption across state markets [1] [2] [3].