Do the Amish get autism?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Was this fact-check helpful?
1. Summary of the results
The analyses provided suggest that the Amish do get autism, but at a lower rate than the general population, with an estimated prevalence of approximately 1 in 271 children [1]. This lower rate may be due to various factors, including cultural norms and customs that influence the reporting style of Amish caregivers [1], as well as socioeconomic and cultural factors [2]. Some sources directly address the myth that Amish children do not have autism due to lower vaccination rates, citing studies that show Amish children are diagnosed with autism at about a third of the national rate [3]. Additionally, case reports provide evidence of Amish individuals with autism, such as an Amish girl with autism, seizures, and hepatomegaly associated with a mutation in the CNTNAP2 gene [4].
2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints
A key omitted fact is the potential impact of genetic variations on the prevalence of autism among the Amish, as some sources suggest that rare genetic variations may contribute to complex psychiatric illnesses, including autism [5]. Furthermore, the analyses highlight the importance of considering socioeconomic and cultural factors when examining autism rates, as these factors may influence the reporting and diagnosis of autism [2]. Alternative viewpoints include the idea that biological differences may also play a role in the lower autism rates among certain populations, such as Hispanic children [2]. It is also worth noting that some sources do not directly address the question of whether the Amish get autism, instead focusing on related topics such as the contribution of rare genetic variations to psychiatric disorders [5].
3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement
The original statement "Do the Amish get autism?" may be misleading, as it implies a simple yes or no answer, when in fact the issue is more complex [1]. The statement may benefit anti-vaccination groups who claim that the Amish do not get autism due to lower vaccination rates, despite evidence to the contrary [3]. On the other hand, the statement may also be used to promote awareness and understanding of autism among the Amish and other populations, highlighting the need for further research and consideration of socioeconomic and cultural factors [2]. Ultimately, the statement may be seen as oversimplifying a complex issue, and may benefit from a more nuanced and informed discussion of the topic [5] [4].