Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Did overall insurance rate increase after affordable care act
Executive summary
Overall premiums in the ACA individual market have risen since the law’s passage, and recent filings show particularly large proposed increases for 2026 — KFF and related analyses find average/median insurer-requested increases in the mid‑teens to mid‑twenties percent range, and analysts warn that if enhanced premium tax credits expire at the end of 2025, subsidized enrollees’ out‑of‑pocket premium payments could jump sharply (estimates range from roughly 75% to more than 100% depending on the analysis) [1] [2] [3].
1. Historical trend: premiums rose, but context matters
Insurers’ filings and independent trackers show that premiums in the ACA marketplaces have generally increased over time, with median proposed increases of about 6–7% for 2024–2025 and much larger proposed hikes for 2026 — a median ~18% in some 2026 filings and KFF estimating an average 26% increase in what insurers charge in 2026 in some analyses [4] [5] [6] [1]. These year‑to‑year changes reflect both routine medical cost inflation and one‑off policy and market changes captured in rate filings [4] [6].
2. Why 2026 looks different: policy uncertainty and drug/hospital cost pressures
Analysts and insurer rate filings attribute the unusually large 2026 increases to a combination of factors: rising hospital and prescription drug costs (including heavy use of GLP‑1 weight‑loss drugs), general medical inflation, and policy uncertainty around the fate of enhanced premium tax credits that were expanded in 2021 and extended through 2025 [7] [4] [1] [6]. Insurers explicitly say they added several percentage points to filings expecting the subsidies to lapse, because they anticipate healthier people would drop coverage, worsening the risk pool [7] [6].
3. The subsidy effect: premiums versus what consumers actually pay
There is an important distinction between the amount insurers charge (gross premiums) and the net premiums that subsidized consumers pay after tax credits. Multiple analyses warn that if enhanced premium tax credits expire at the end of 2025, the monthly or annual payments for subsidized enrollees could rise dramatically — KFF estimates average premium payments could more than double (~114% increase) for subsidized enrollees in that scenario, while other analysts cite increases “over 75%” on average — because many who previously received bigger subsidies would get much less or none [3] [2] [1]. Those figures incorporate both insurer rate requests and the mechanical effect of losing subsidy help [3] [2].
4. Variation across states and plans: not a uniform story
State choices — such as running a state marketplace, using reinsurance, or Medicaid expansion — affect how much premiums move. Analyses found wide state variation for 2026 filings: some states saw >30% increases while others stayed below 10%, and population‑weighted national estimates differ (e.g., MoneyGeek’s 50‑state analysis found a 20% national rise, while KFF/others report different averages depending on sample and weighting) [8] [1] [6]. That means individual experience will depend heavily on geography and plan selection [8] [5].
5. Competing interpretations and political framing
Different outlets frame the numbers for different audiences. Advocacy groups emphasize the consumer pain if subsidies expire and call the likely outcome a “skyrocket” in costs [9] [3]. Policy trackers and research centers focus on granular drivers in rate filings and emphasize insurer assumptions and market dynamics [7] [6]. Conservative outlets highlight fiscal and administrative choices behind subsidy extensions or cutoffs; some reporting links the subsidy debate to partisan standoffs around budget negotiations [10]. Readers should note these differing emphases reflect each source’s priorities and audience [9] [10] [11].
6. What the sources don’t settle (limits of current reporting)
Available sources do not mention a definitive single nationwide percentage that consumers will pay in 2026 because outcomes depend on whether Congress extends enhanced tax credits, final regulator-approved rates (not preliminary filings), and individual circumstances like income, family size and state [3] [2] [6]. They also do not provide long‑term trend projections beyond short‑term filings without modeling different legislative scenarios [1] [6].
7. Bottom line for readers
Yes — overall insurer premiums in the ACA individual market have increased since the ACA’s enactment, and filings show substantially larger proposed increases for 2026; however, how much any individual household’s costs rise depends critically on whether the enhanced premium tax credits are extended, final approved rates, geographic variation, and plan choice [4] [1] [3]. If Congress allows the enhanced credits to lapse, many subsidized enrollees face much larger out‑of‑pocket premium bills (estimates from roughly “over 75%” to “about 114%” average increases are reported) [2] [3].