Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How are ACA subsidy amounts calculated based on income?
Executive summary
Premium tax credits (ACA subsidies) are calculated from your household’s ACA-specific modified adjusted gross income (MAGI), the federal poverty level (FPL) for your household size, and the local cost of the “benchmark” plan (the second‑lowest‑cost Silver plan); the government sets a maximum share of income you must pay for that benchmark and pays the remainder as a credit [1] [2]. Between 2021–2025 the American Rescue Plan/Inflation Reduction Act removed the 400% FPL cliff and capped household contributions so no one pays more than about 8.5% of income for the benchmark plan; unless Congress acts, the enhanced rules expire after 2025 and the pre‑2021 structure (including a 400% cap) would return [3] [4] [5].
1. How the math works in plain language
The Marketplace starts with your estimated annual household MAGI (wages, self‑employment, most taxable income) and compares it to the federal poverty guideline for your household size to produce a percent‑of‑FPL number; that percentage places you in a table that assigns a maximum expected contribution rate (a share of income) toward the benchmark Silver premium. The subsidy equals the gap between that required contribution and the benchmark premium; the credit is paid to the insurer so you pay only the lower net premium [1] [2].
2. The benchmark plan and local variation matter
Subsidy size depends heavily on where you live because the benchmark plan—the second‑lowest‑cost Silver plan—varies by county and insurer. Two households with identical incomes and household sizes can receive very different credits if benchmark premiums differ in their areas [1] [6]. FactCheck.org and KFF examples show high‑income families in expensive regions may still qualify for large credits under enhanced rules, illustrating geographic impact [6].
3. The temporary “enhanced” rules, and what changed through 2025
The American Rescue Plan [7] and its extension in later legislation replaced the old 400% FPL cutoff with a requirement that no one pay more than a capped percentage of income for the benchmark (about 8.5% at the floor), meaning subsidies extended above 400% FPL for people whose benchmark costs would otherwise exceed that percent. Those enhancements are in effect through 2025; many tools and analyses assume they will expire unless Congress acts [3] [4] [5].
4. What to use for income and for which year
Marketplaces use your estimated income for the coverage year and compare it to the most recent published FPL table (for example, 2025 FPL numbers are used to calculate subsidies for 2026 coverage). If your actual income differs when you file taxes, reconciliation occurs via Form 8962 and you may owe money back or receive additional credit [8] [4] [2].
5. Practical implications and repayment limits
The subsidy is an advanceable tax credit paid monthly; if you receive more credit than you’re entitled to (because income turned out higher), you generally must reconcile on your tax return. Repayment caps and limits vary by income band; some calculators and guides provide estimated repayment caps and required contribution percentages for 2025 figures [8] [9]. Exact repayment caps and percentages used for calculation are updated annually by the IRS and reflected in marketplace tools [8] [9].
6. Tools, estimates, and uncertainty about 2026
Several non‑government calculators (KFF, HealthInsurance.org, ValuePenguin) let you estimate subsidies and show large differences depending on whether enhanced subsidies continue into 2026; many analysts warn that if the enhancements lapse, eligibility will revert to the pre‑2021 rules with a hard 400%‑of‑FPL cutoff and smaller credits for many households [3] [9] [10]. KFF’s calculator and analyses explicitly model both scenarios and were updated with 2026 premium and IRS guidance when available [9] [2].
7. Competing viewpoints and policy stakes
Policy analysts differ on who benefits most: some defenders of the enhancements highlight that most subsidy dollars go to households earning under roughly $150,000 and that enhanced subsidies sharply lowered premiums for low‑ and middle‑income people [6] [5]. Critics point out cost and distribution concerns; CRFB and other budget analysts emphasize the large federal cost growth tied to enhanced credits [5]. Policymakers face tradeoffs between reducing out‑of‑pocket burdens and federal budget impact [5] [6].
Limitations and where to look next: official IRS rules (Form 8962/publications) and your state Marketplace provide the exact formulas, current contribution tables and repayment caps; available sources above summarize and model those rules but do not replace IRS or HHS guidance [8] [2].