Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How to choose the right size penis pump?
Executive summary
Most sellers and makers advise measuring both erect length and erect girth, then choosing a cylinder about 2–3 inches longer than your erect penis and with an internal diameter that leaves roughly a 1/4"–comfortable clearance around your girth; several brand guides repeat this rule of thumb (e.g., Bathmate, LA Pump, The Enhanced Male) [1] [2] [3]. Guidance also stresses safety: a tube that’s too large can pull in the testicles and be ineffective, while a tube that’s too small can cause pain or skin damage — so many vendors recommend precise measuring and, where offered, multi-stage cylinders or multiple sizes [1] [4] [2].
1. Measure like the manufacturers tell you — length and girth matter
Every practical sizing guide in the results starts with measurements taken when erect: bone-pressed erect length (BPEL) for length and circumference at the thickest point for girth. Bathmate and LA Pump explicitly tell you to measure erect rather than flaccid and to press the ruler to the pubic bone for accuracy [1] [2]. Multiple vendors offer calculators or charts that convert circumference to an internal tube diameter and length recommendations [5] [6] [7].
2. Use the common “+2–3 inches” length rule, but know why
Vendors repeatedly recommend choosing a cylinder 2–3 inches longer than your erect length so there’s airspace for safe vacuum modulation and to prevent the testicles from being drawn in; Bathmate, Extenderz and several retailers state this directly [1] [8] [3]. The Pumptoys sizing guidance explains that some airspace cushions the vacuum and produces more even engorgement across penile tissues [4].
3. Translate girth to diameter — the 1/4" clearance and why it matters
Cylinder diameter is typically chosen from circumference measurements. LA Pump and The Enhanced Male advise accounting for roughly 1/4" of extra diameter if you’re at a borderline measurement, since a too-tight opening makes exit difficult and can be dangerous [2] [3]. Pump-to-chart examples show how circumference converts to diameter (e.g., 5.5" circumference ≈ 1.75" diameter and a 2.0" tube is suggested) [4].
4. Staged pumping and multiple cylinders: a common vendor recommendation
Manufacturers and retailers often offer two-stage cylinders or advise owning multiple sizes so you can “fill” a tube and then finish in a larger one; PenisPumpsOnline and Pumptoys describe staged use to equalize tissue stretching and reduce uneven results [5] [4]. LA Pump’s two-stage sizing also instructs measuring around penis and scrotum for certain cylinder types [2].
5. Safety signals — when size is wrong or you’re risking harm
Sources warn that a cylinder that’s too big may draw in testicles and reduce effectiveness, while one that’s too small can cause soreness, skin peeling, or extreme pain [1] [7]. Advice includes not pumping to pain, limiting continuous use (some sellers note 20 minutes max), and using pumps with safety release valves or vacuum gauges for control [7].
6. Where vendor advice diverges and what that means for shoppers
Most commercial sources agree on core rules (measure erect, leave space, 2–3" extra length). Differences show up in exact tolerance, conversion charts, and whether to measure flaccid if you can’t get erect (some calculators won’t work without erection; Bathmate’s tool requires erect measurements) [9] [6]. That divergence is less about science and more about product design differences and sellers protecting against returns — LA Pump even notes legal limits on returns for medical devices and urges careful sizing [2].
7. Practical checklist before you buy
Measure erect length bone-pressed and erect girth at thickest point [5] [1]. Pick a cylinder 2–3" longer than BPEL and choose diameter per the girth-to-diameter chart, adding ~1/4" if you’re borderline [3] [4] [2]. Consider staged sets or buying the next size up for progression [5]. Choose a pump with a safety release valve or vacuum gauge and follow time/sensation limits advised by the vendor [7].
Limitations and conflicts in reporting: the guidance comes from manufacturers and retailers, not independent clinical trials, and while they converge on practical sizing rules, “best” sizing can vary by pump design — available sources do not cite randomized clinical evidence comparing sizing strategies (not found in current reporting). Use these vendor-sourced rules as practical buying and safety guidance, and consult a clinician if you’re using a pump for erectile dysfunction or experience pain [1] [7].