Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: What are estimates of Medicaid costs specifically for undocumented immigrants in 2023–2024?
Executive Summary
The available analyses indicate there is no single, comprehensive nationwide estimate of total Medicaid spending specifically for undocumented immigrants in 2023–2024; instead, researchers and agencies report emergency Medicaid spending figures and state snapshots that serve as proxies for costs tied to noncitizen populations [1] [2] [3]. Federal reporting and journalistic summaries converge on the finding that emergency Medicaid spending for noncitizen immigrants is small relative to total Medicaid — estimates put emergency Medicaid at well under 1% of overall Medicaid spending in recent years, with multi-year totals in the low tens of billions [3] [4].
1. Clear claims extracted: what analysts and reports actually say, not what they imply
The assembled sources make several distinct claims that must be separated: first, federal and state governments collectively spent billions on emergency Medicaid for noncitizens between 2017 and 2023, with one CBO-derived figure indicating about $27 billion for that period and another breakdown of roughly $18 billion federal and $9 billion state [2] [5]. Second, emergency Medicaid comprised a very small share of total Medicaid spending, with one analysis citing emergency Medicaid at 0.4% of total Medicaid in FY2023 and $3.8 billion spent that year for emergency services for ineligible non-U.S. nationals [3]. Third, state-level patterns vary, illustrated by New York’s emergency Medicaid tripling in roughly a decade to $639 million in fiscal 2023–24 in one state-focused report [6]. These claims are distinct: aggregate multi-year totals, single-year shares of national spending, and state-specific expenditures.
2. What the recent numbers show and how they were derived
National-level estimates in the provided material rely largely on CBO-style accounting and Medicaid reporting that isolates emergency care for noncitizens who are ineligible for full Medicaid due to immigration status [2] [4]. The $27 billion cumulative figure for 2017–2023 and the $3.8 billion single-year emergency Medicaid number for FY2023 come from analyses summarizing federal and state emergency-care claims; such figures exclude routine, non-emergency Medicaid services that undocumented people generally cannot access. State breakdowns show big variation: New York’s emergency Medicaid spending increased from about $207 million in 2013–14 to $639 million in 2023–24 for undocumented immigrants — a near-tripling reflecting policy shifts, population changes, and possibly reporting differences [6]. These numbers are specialty-line items within Medicaid accounting, not full estimates of health costs for undocumented immigrants.
3. Comparing the different perspectives: scale, scope, and framing
Sources emphasizing multi-year cumulative totals frame the issue as a measurable but limited fiscal burden at the federal and state levels, while fact-summaries like KFF and other journalists emphasize relative scale — that emergency Medicaid is under 1% of total Medicaid spending [3] [4]. The CBO-derived cumulative totals and state spikes are not contradictory: a small annual share can still accumulate to tens of billions over multiple years, and some states experience sharper increases due to local policy choices or demographic trends. The framing matters: advocacy or political actors may highlight either the cumulative dollars or the low percentage of total Medicaid spending to support contrasting policy messages. Both framings are factually supported by the presented data, but they emphasize different policy narratives [2] [4].
4. Limits and important omissions in the available estimates
None of the provided sources purport to estimate total Medicaid spending for undocumented immigrants in 2023–2024 across all categories of care because federal rules generally restrict undocumented people from comprehensive Medicaid aside from emergency services and narrow state-funded programs [1] [7]. The reported figures therefore exclude out-of-pocket care, uncompensated care billed to hospitals, state-funded programs that expand coverage to some immigrants, and any Medicaid-like services paid at state or local levels outside standard Medicaid accounting. Variations in state reporting, program definitions, and whether emergency claims are correctly attributed to immigration status further limit precision. Consequently, any headline claiming a definitive nationwide Medicaid cost for undocumented immigrants in 2023–24 would be unsupported by these sources [1] [3].
5. Bottom line: what can policymakers and citizens reliably conclude?
Based on the provided analyses, the reliable conclusions are clear: emergency Medicaid spending for noncitizen immigrants is measurable but small relative to total Medicaid, amounting to a few billion dollars per year nationally and accumulating to low tens of billions across several years [3] [2]. State-level spikes show meaningful local fiscal effects in places like New York, where emergency Medicaid for undocumented immigrants grew substantially between 2013–14 and 2023–24 [6]. Missing from the records are comprehensive nationwide totals of all Medicaid-like spending for undocumented immigrants because federal eligibility limits and diverse state practices create unavoidable gaps. Further precision would require harmonized federal-state reporting that separates emergency and non-emergency claims by immigration status and documents state-funded programs explicitly [1] [2].