Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How will Obamacare subsidy expiration affect health insurance premiums in 2025?
Executive summary
If Congress does not extend the enhanced Affordable Care Act (ACA) premium tax credits that expire at the end of 2025, marketplace enrollees would face large out‑of‑pocket premium increases in 2026 — KFF and other analysts estimate average premium payments for subsidized enrollees would more than double (from about $888 in 2025 to roughly $1,904 in 2026, a 114% increase) and CBO projects gross benchmark premiums would rise about 4.3% in 2026 due in part to a sicker risk pool [1] [2]. Analysts also warn millions could lose coverage and broader economic effects [3] [4].
1. Why the change would happen: the policy cliff and what expires
The “enhanced” premium tax credits — expanded eligibility and lower required household contributions enacted under ARPA and extended by the Inflation Reduction Act — are scheduled to revert to pre‑pandemic rules after December 31, 2025; unless Congress acts, the temporary enhancements expire and subsidy caps tighten starting January 1, 2026 [5] [6]. That statutory rollback directly increases the share of premiums households must pay and removes the extra help that kept many low‑ and middle‑income premiums low in recent years [5].
2. Direct impact on what people would pay: big increases for many
KFF’s modeling finds that the average subsidized enrollee’s annual premium payment would rise from about $888 in 2025 to $1,904 in 2026 — a $1,016 increase and a 114% jump on average if enhanced credits lapse [1] [7]. Other policy briefs give concrete household examples — e.g., a family of four earning roughly $45,000 could go from $0 premiums in 2025 to roughly $1,607 annually without the enhancement — underscoring that impacts vary by income, family size, age and state [5] [8].
3. Insurer pricing and risk‑pool effects: supply‑side reasons premiums might rise further
Beyond subsidy math, non‑subsidy factors amplify premium changes. The Congressional Budget Office estimated that gross benchmark premiums would increase because less generous subsidies would prompt healthier people to drop coverage, worsening the risk pool; CBO cited a 4.3% average increase in gross benchmark premiums for 2026 if enhancements aren’t extended [2]. Budget and fiscal analysts similarly point to estimated pre‑subsidy premium increases around 5% from shifts in enrollment and risk composition [4].
4. Coverage and economic ripple effects: not just sticker shock
Multiple estimates warn of substantial coverage losses and economic fallout if enhancements lapse. Urban Institute and Commonwealth Fund analyses project millions could lose marketplace coverage and several million could become uninsured; related work links those coverage shifts to potential job and economic impacts nationwide [3]. Those ripple effects feed back into premiums and health‑system strain in some states, according to analysts [6] [3].
5. Political and budget tradeoffs: why extension is contested
Extending the enhancements is costly — estimates put a full permanent extension in the hundreds of billions over a decade — and critics argue it creates fiscal pressure and may channel funds to higher‑income enrollees or insurers; proponents counter that extensions preserve affordability and prevent large coverage losses [9] [10] [11]. The debate is active in Congress and the White House, where officials are discussing alternatives and tradeoffs as a December vote approaches [12] [10].
6. How impacts will vary by state, age and income
The dollar and percentage impact differs markedly across geographies and demographics. KFF and other calculators show that some enrollees now paying very low or zero premiums would face substantial bills without enhanced credits, while higher‑cost areas or older enrollees could see particularly large increases [7] [11]. States that supplement federal subsidies or run their own marketplaces may see different outcomes (available sources do not mention specific state‑by‑state supplemental policies beyond general notes) [7].
7. Uncertainties and what to watch this fall/winter
Key uncertainties include congressional action (extensions, partial fixes, or new formulas), insurer rate‑filings for 2026 (which feed into net premium outcomes), and behavioral responses by enrollees (who might drop coverage). Watch for legislative moves, CBO updates on premium and enrollment projections, KFF interactive updates, and White House and administration proposals that could replace or reshape subsidy rules [2] [1] [12].
Limitations: reporting and analyses differ in scope (some emphasize average dollar impacts, others focus on macro premium changes or coverage counts), and detailed state‑level modeling or insurer reaction beyond the cited sources is not provided here (available sources do not mention employer responses or state‑specific mitigation plans in detail).