Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: How do the projected premium increases compare to previous years' rate hikes?
Executive Summary
Projected premium increases this year are modest in some markets but dramatic in others: healthcare Marketplace benchmark premiums rose about 5.8% from 2024 to 2025, a step up from the prior year but within recent healthcare growth patterns [1]. Homeowners’ property insurance premiums, by contrast, surged roughly 30–33% from 2020 to 2023, driven chiefly by rising reinsurance costs and concentrated in disaster-prone areas [2] [3]. The gap reflects different underlying drivers and market structures across insurance lines.
1. What the reports actually claim — a concise inventory that matters
The dataset contains three clear, competing claims about premium trajectories. First, academic analyses document a large, rapid rise in U.S. homeowners’ property premiums — roughly 30–33% between 2020 and 2023, increasing average annual premiums from around $1,902 to $2,530 and attributing most of that to reinsurance cost pass-through [2] [3]. Second, federal health‑market data show Marketplace benchmark premiums increased 5.8% from 2024 to 2025, higher than the 4.2% year-over-year rise the prior year, and comparable to recent GDP growth [1]. Third, industry-wide international reports note strong nominal premium growth in non-life and personal lines globally — mid-to-high single digits to low double digits in recent years, reflecting broader market repricing [4] [5] [6]. Each claim is internally consistent but addresses different slices of the insurance landscape.
2. Comparing short-term rate hikes to the recent long-run picture
When placed side-by-side, the short-term health-insurance increase (5.8% in 2025) is modest relative to the multi-year property-insurance surge (about 30%+ since 2020), indicating distinct temporal patterns [1] [2]. The health number is a one-year benchmark movement that is larger than the prior year’s single-year increase but sits within a decade-long pattern of steady growth in individual market premiums [7]. The property figure is cumulative over several years and therefore reflects compounded shocks tied to catastrophe exposures and market reinsurance cycles rather than annual pricing dynamics alone [3]. Directly comparing a single-year health change with a three-year property cumulative jump overstates similarity; the proper comparison is to annualized property changes, which still show rates well above typical pre-2020 single-year moves [2].
3. Where increases are concentrated — geography and product matter
The evidence shows substantial heterogeneity: homeowners in hurricane- and wildfire-prone regions faced the largest premium spikes, while other areas saw milder rises [3]. Health‑market premiums vary by plan type and state regulatory environments: individual plans historically grew faster than large-group plans over the 2011–2021 decade, underscoring structural differences across product lines [7]. Global industry reports corroborate that personal lines and non-life segments experienced outsized nominal growth in 2022–23, but that growth reflects a mix of rate increases and changing exposure, and it varies significantly by market and jurisdiction [4] [5]. Aggregate headline rates mask important local and product-level disparities that determine consumer impact.
4. What’s driving the divergence — reinsurance, disasters, and macro forces
Multiple analyses converge on reinsurance cost escalation and disaster exposure as the primary driver for homeowners’ premium jumps, with reinsurance rates roughly doubling between 2018 and 2023 and insurers passing those costs to policyholders [2] [3]. For health Marketplace premiums, the immediate drivers appear more tied to general healthcare cost trends, claims experience, and macroeconomic pressures that pushed the 2025 benchmark up by 5.8%, a faster pace than the prior year but closer to broader economic growth rates [1]. Industry-wide reports add that inflation, capital market conditions, and underwriting results contributed to above-average premium growth in non-life globally in 2023 [4] [6]. Different drivers explain different magnitudes of change across lines.
5. What the numbers mean for consumers — affordability and exposure
For homeowners in high-risk areas, a 30%+ increase over three years materially alters affordability and mortgage escrow calculations, potentially pricing some households out of traditional insurance markets and increasing the number of underinsured properties [2]. For individuals shopping on the health Marketplace, a 5.8% rise in the benchmark premium is meaningful but less likely to produce abrupt coverage loss, especially where subsidies offset costs; nonetheless it signals upward pressure on out-of-pocket commitments and plan choice [1] [7]. International premium growth trends imply broader cost pressures that may translate into tighter coverage terms or higher deductibles, depending on local regulation and insurer strategies [5]. Consumers face different financial risks depending on line and location.
6. Conflicting narratives and the agendas they serve — follow the context
Reports emphasizing dramatic property premium hikes foreground climate and reinsurance pressures and can prompt calls for federal or state intervention to stabilize markets [2] [3]. Conversely, coverage of single-year Marketplace increases often situates the change within standard actuarial cycles and macro trends, which can temper calls for immediate policy remedies [1] [7]. Industry and OECD/IAIS accounts frame premium rises as market corrections after years of soft pricing, which suits insurer narratives supporting rate adequacy [4] [5] [6]. Readers should interpret each headline with its scope in mind: product type, time frame, and geographic concentration fundamentally shape the policy and consumer implications.