Which Salmonella strains were involved in peanut butter recalls from 2020 to 2025?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
From 2020–2025, public reporting and federal notices about peanut butter recalls captured at least one clear contemporary strain—Salmonella Senftenberg—tied to a 2022 recall of Jif-brand peanut butter; historical context in the literature and public-health archives also shows other serotypes have driven major peanut-butter–related recalls and outbreaks in earlier years, notably Salmonella Typhimurium (Peanut Corporation of America in 2008–2009) and Salmonella Tennessee (described in scientific reviews of past peanut butter outbreaks) [1] [2] [3] [4]. The available sources document Senftenberg as the strain responsible for the 2022 Jif recall and confirm Typhimurium and Tennessee as previously implicated serotypes in significant peanut/peanut-butter events, but do not provide an exhaustive list of every strain involved in every recall from 2020–2025 [1] [2] [3] [4].
1. The 2022 Jif recall: Salmonella Senftenberg identified
Federal outbreak investigations in 2022 linked a multistate illness cluster to certain Jif-brand peanut butter produced at J.M. Smucker’s Lexington, Kentucky facility, and whole genome sequencing and epidemiologic data identified Salmonella Senftenberg as the outbreak strain prompting voluntary recalls and downstream recalls of products made with that peanut butter [1] [5] [2].
2. Why Senftenberg matters: public-health response and scope
Public-health agencies including the FDA and CDC publicly advised consumers, retailers, and institutions to discard affected lot codes of Jif peanut butter because the Senftenberg-matched environmental and product samples corresponded to reported illnesses across multiple states, triggering corporate, retail and manufacturer removals as well as warnings about long shelf life and recalled derivative products [1] [2] [6].
3. Historical precedents: Typhimurium and the scale of past recalls
Major peanut-butter recalls and one of the largest U.S. foodborne outbreaks (Peanut Corporation of America, 2008–2009) were linked to Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium; state and federal notices and public-health summaries identify Typhimurium as the strain traced to the PCA plant that led to thousands of product recalls, illnesses, hospitalizations and deaths, and consequential regulatory fallout [3] [7].
4. Salmonella Tennessee: an earlier technical and research focus
Scientific analyses of peanut butter thermal inactivation and outbreak microbiology highlight Salmonella Tennessee as another serotype implicated in prior peanut/paste outbreaks and used in laboratory comparisons of thermal resistance—illustrating that multiple serotypes beyond Typhimurium have historically been associated with peanut products and that some strains may show greater heat resistance in peanut matrices [4].
5. Limits of available reporting for 2020–2025 and what the sources do not show
The assembled sources explicitly document Senftenberg for the 2022 Jif recalls and cite Typhimurium and Tennessee in major historical outbreaks and research, but they do not present a comprehensive, year-by-year catalog of all Salmonella serotypes tied to every peanut-butter recall between 2020 and 2025; absence of a strain in these sources should not be read as proof it was never involved—rather, the present reporting simply does not enumerate additional serotypes for that specific 2020–2025 window [1] [4] [3].
6. Conflicting emphases and institutional agendas in reporting
Regulatory press releases and news outlets focused on brand-level recalls and consumer safety warnings (for example FDA and state health pages emphasizing lot codes and disposal), while scientific reviews emphasize laboratory characteristics of particular serotypes (such as Tennessee’s heat resistance), revealing differing institutional priorities: consumer protection and rapid recall action on one hand, and deeper mechanistic study and risk mitigation on the other; some trade and legal reporting historically has centered on liability and supply-chain impact rather than strain taxonomy [1] [5] [4] [7].
7. Bottom line for readers tracking strains
For the 2020–2025 reporting captured by the supplied sources, Salmonella Senftenberg is the documented causative strain for the 2022 Jif peanut butter recalls, while the record and scientific literature point to Salmonella Typhimurium and Salmonella Tennessee as important, historically implicated serotypes in major peanut/peanut-butter outbreaks—yet the sources do not supply a complete roster of all serotypes involved in every recall during 2020–2025, leaving room for further verification through FDA/CDC recall databases and state public-health confirmations [1] [2] [3] [4].