Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: Approximately how many non-Jewish civilians were killed during the Holocaust
Executive Summary
Approximately 5 million non-Jewish victims is the commonly cited estimate of non-Jewish people murdered by the Nazis and their allies during the Holocaust, a figure that when combined with the approximately 6 million Jewish victims yields the widely quoted total of about 11 million victims; however, alternative estimates and misunderstandings expand or contest that number by conflating genocide with wartime casualties, producing much larger and less precise totals. Scholarly and museum-based sources represented in the provided materials present both the 5 million figure and critiques that this number can be misapplied or misinterpreted, so the best-supported concise answer from these analyses is roughly 5 million non-Jewish victims [1] [2].
1. Why the “5 million non-Jewish” figure gained traction and what it covers
The 5 million non-Jewish number appears prominently in institutional summaries and educational materials as the complement to the roughly 6 million Jewish victims to produce the oft-repeated total of 11 million people murdered under Nazi policies. This aggregation is intended to capture groups specifically targeted for persecution and mass murder: Soviet prisoners of war, ethnic Poles, Roma (Gypsies), people with disabilities, political opponents, Jehovah’s Witnesses, and others who were killed for ideological, racial, or political reasons. The texts in the dossier repeatedly present that combined estimate as a working figure to express the scale of Nazi mass murder beyond the Jewish genocide, and they emphasize it as an educational shorthand to communicate the broader scope of Nazi crimes [1] [2].
2. Where the higher estimates and disputes come from—and why they matter
Some analyses and materials included in the provided set push back on the simplicity of the 11 million total, arguing that larger figures—sometimes cited as tens of millions—derive from conflating genocidal killings with wider wartime casualties, demographic losses, and military deaths. One source in the dataset explicitly cautions that claims of 30–35 million non-Jewish victims mix genocide with wartime deaths and thus overstate the count of people murdered specifically as victims of Nazi persecution [3]. The distinction matters because it affects historical accountability, the study of intent versus collateral wartime loss, and memorialization; scholars and educators in the materials urge careful differentiation between intentional genocidal murder and broader war-related fatalities so that victims and perpetrators are accurately characterized [3] [4].
3. Group-by-group numbers: consensus, uncertainty, and the Roma example
The dossier highlights group-specific estimates where available, and shows clearer ranges for some categories than others. For example, the Roma (also called Romani or Sinti) are estimated in these materials at between roughly 250,000 and 500,000 killed by the Nazi regime—an estimate that is lower than Jewish losses but still significant and recognized as genocide by many scholars and institutions. Other groups—Soviet POWs, non-Jewish Poles, and people with disabilities—are acknowledged as numbering in the millions collectively, but precise breakdowns vary and remain subject to ongoing research, making the aggregate ~5 million non-Jewish an approximate but defensible figure for the victims targeted as part of Nazi persecution policies [5] [6] [2].
4. Education and public understanding: where simplifications help and where they harm
Educational materials cited in the dataset warn that over-simplified totals can both help communicate scale and also obscure distinct experiences. The 11 million summary—6 million Jews plus 5 million non-Jews—functions as a memorable way to convey the Holocaust’s breadth, but it risks flattening the unique histories and forms of persecution suffered by different groups. Several items emphasize that students and the public often lack awareness of non-Jewish victims’ experiences and that instruction should differentiate the methods, motives, and legal meanings of crimes against each group to avoid erasure or false equivalence [7] [1].
5. Reconciling numbers: best practice and the responsible conclusion
Given the materials provided, the most defensible, evidence-aligned response is that approximately 5 million non-Jewish civilians and others were murdered by Nazi Germany and its allies as part of genocidal and political-persecution policies, recognizing that this figure is an estimate and that some sources criticize misuse of the total when it incorporates battlefield and civilian wartime casualties not attributable to targeted extermination. Responsible communication requires stating the ~5 million figure while noting uncertainties, group-specific ranges (e.g., 250–500k Roma), and the separate category of wartime casualties, so readers understand both the scale and the methodological limits of these estimates [1] [5] [3].