Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What was the total number of US deportations in calendar year 2024?
Executive Summary
The total number of U.S. deportations in calendar year 2024 cannot be stated as a single, unambiguous figure from the sources provided because federal data are reported on different bases: ICE reports 271,484 removals for Fiscal Year 2024 (Oct 1, 2023–Sep 30, 2024), while DHS reporting on repatriations through November 2024 shows a markedly larger flow of returns (roughly 678,000 repatriations through November) that mixes removals, returns, and expulsions handled by multiple agencies. Determining a clean calendar-year 2024 total requires combining ICE ERO removals, CBP expulsions/returns (including Title 42-era expulsions and other returns), and any other repatriation categories, and reconciling reporting periods and definitions before and after September 30, 2024 [1] [2] [3].
1. Why the Easy Answer is Wrong: Fiscal Year Numbers Don’t Equal Calendar Year Totals
ICE’s headline figure that dominated reporting—271,484 ERO removals in FY2024—is indisputable within ICE’s fiscal reporting but covers October 2023 through September 2024, not January–December 2024. This distinction matters because roughly three months of removals that occurred in calendar-year 2024 (January–September) are captured in FY2024, while removals from October–December 2024 fall into FY2025. Any attempt to state “total deportations in calendar 2024” by citing ICE’s FY2024 number conflates fiscal and calendar reporting periods and will either undercount or double-count depending on how Q4 FY2024 and Q1 FY2025 data are handled. ICE itself and analysts caution about this mismatch and the need for cross-agency reconciliation [4] [5].
2. Multiple Systems, Multiple Definitions: Removals vs. Repatriations vs. Expulsions
Federal agencies use different operational categories that are not interchangeable. ICE reports “removals” (enforced returns under immigration law) and voluntary returns it processes; CBP reports expulsions and Title 42 removals/returns at the border; DHS compiles broader “repatriations” that can include removals, voluntary returns, and expulsions. The DHS/USAFacts-style reporting that shows ~678,000 repatriations through November 2024 aggregates multiple pathways of people leaving the United States and therefore substantially exceeds ICE ERO removals alone. Any accurate calendar-year total must specify which categories are included and note which agencies’ counts are being summed [2] [3].
3. Cross-Checks and Contradictions: What the Different Reports Emphasize
ICE’s FY2024 annual report emphasizes enforcement priorities and criminal-history metrics—reporting 271,484 removals to 192 countries and highlighting that about a third had criminal histories—framing the number as an enforcement success relative to prior years [1] [6]. In contrast, DHS-level repatriation tallies presented in November and summarized later present much larger counts, showing monthly repatriation averages spiking during 2024 and indicating operations at the Southwest border and CBP expulsions as major drivers. The two perspectives are consistent on the trend—higher removal/repatriation activity in 2024 versus prior years—but they present different slices of the same movement and therefore can be misread as contradictory unless definitions are made explicit [7] [2].
4. What’s Missing If You Want a Calendar-Only Total
To produce a rigorous calendar-year 2024 number you need synchronized, de-duplicated data from ICE (ERO removals and returns), CBP (expulsions/Title 42-era returns and expulsions), and DHS compilations that reconcile overlaps and categorize voluntary vs. enforced departures. None of the supplied sources offers that reconciled calendar-year total: ICE gives FY totals, CBP expulsions are referenced but not totaled in the provided extracts, and DHS repatriation snapshots stop at November 2024 without a fully reconciled December 2024 figure. Analysts must also watch for double-counting (e.g., CBP-processed expulsions later reflected in ICE tallies) and for definitional shifts after policy changes [8] [7].
5. How to Answer Precisely—and What Each Agency’s Number Tells You
If you want a defensible calendar-year figure right now, the transparent path is to request or compute: ICE removals from Jan–Sep 2024 (subset of FY2024), plus ICE removals Oct–Dec 2024 (from FY2025 reporting), plus CBP expulsions/returns for Jan–Dec 2024, then remove overlaps. The provided materials show the pieces: ICE FY2024 = 271,484 removals (core evidence of elevated enforcement); DHS repatriations ≈ 678,000 through Nov 2024 (evidence of larger cross-agency repatriation flows). Those two published numbers, taken together, demonstrate that an exact calendar-year total must be assembled rather than assumed from a single headline statistic [1] [2] [5].
6. Motives and Messaging: Why Different Actors Emphasize Different Numbers
ICE’s annual report emphasizes ERO removals and criminal-history metrics to underline enforcement gains and resource allocation priorities; DHS and data aggregators phrase larger repatriation totals to capture the scale of border returns and expulsions—each framing supports differing policy narratives. Recognize these agendas when interpreting headlines: agency reports highlight operational accomplishments, while cross-agency tallies highlight systemic flows that may be of interest to migration researchers and policymakers. For an authoritative calendar-year 2024 total, insist on reconciled, de-duplicated, agency-by-agency data covering Jan–Dec 2024 [1] [2].