Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How did the 2024 US city murder rates compare to the national average?
Executive Summary
The available analyses show that 2024 U.S. murder rates declined from 2023 and sat near or below recent multi‑year averages, but city‑level patterns varied widely: some cities recorded very high homicide rates while many others were below the national figure. Nationwide estimates put the 2024 homicide rate around 5.0–5.6 per 100,000 residents, a sizable drop from pandemic‑era peaks, while select cities such as St. Louis remained extreme outliers with rates an order of magnitude higher than the national average [1] [2] [3]. The differing datasets reflect variation in city samples, definitions, and reporting windows, so the headline is that the national trend in 2024 was downward, but local experience diverged sharply [4] [2].
1. Why the national picture looks better — a clear drop in murder rates
Multiple independent analyses converge on a substantial year‑over‑year decline in 2024, with the FBI’s aggregated reporting and contemporary summaries indicating a drop in murders and nonnegligent manslaughter of roughly 14.9 percent versus 2023 and an overall national homicide rate near 5 per 100,000—the lowest in roughly a decade [1] [4]. This national improvement is corroborated by estimates that violent crime fell about 4.5 percent in 2024, and that the cadence of homicide incidents slowed to an average interval of one murder every 31.1 minutes in 2024, down from higher frequencies in prior years [5] [4]. These figures reflect broad national trends rather than uniform local change and depend on final FBI compilation for exactitude [1].
2. City-level variation: many cities fell, but a few drove stark contrasts
City data for 2024 show large heterogeneity: among a 24‑city sample, the range in homicide rates spanned roughly 50.7 points per 100,000, and about 71 percent of those cities saw declines from 2023 to 2024, with Greensboro registering the largest single‑city drop (43.1 percent) while St. Louis remained the highest‑rate outlier at 54.4 per 100,000 [2]. Other large cities followed different trajectories—some mid‑sized places held steady or improved modestly, while historically high‑rate cities continued to record elevated per‑capita murder rates. The result is that national averages mask extreme local differences, so comparing any single city to the national average requires careful attention to sample and numerator/denominator definitions [2] [3].
3. Reconciling different published national rates and samples
Analysts cite slightly different national homicide rates for 2024—5.0 per 100,000 in FBI summaries versus 5.6 per 100,000 in a 24‑city summary—because of differences in scope: the FBI’s national statistic includes the full country and standardized definitions, whereas city compilations may cover either a subset of large cities or rely on local reports and provisional counts [1] [2]. Historical context shows the national rate has been above 6 per 100,000 since 2020 and fell through 2023 into 2024, so both the FBI’s lower national estimate and the higher city‑sample average are consistent once one accounts for selection bias toward cities with elevated crime and timing differences in reporting windows [3] [4] [2]. Analysts should therefore note methodology before inferring substantive contradictions.
4. What this means for policy debates and media narratives
The combined evidence undermines simplistic claims that 2024 was uniformly more lawless or uniformly safer: nationally, murder rates fell meaningfully, yet certain cities remain persistently hot spots that dominate public perception and policy attention [1] [2]. Advocacy groups and political actors can selectively cite either the national decline or the high city outliers to advance policing, social service, or criminal‑justice reform agendas; readers should therefore watch for sample selection and headline framing. Reporting that emphasizes a single figure without disclosing whether it is a national FBI rate or a sample average from particular cities risks misleading policymakers and the public [2] [3].
5. Bottom line: general improvement but local caution required
The most defensible conclusion from the available analyses is that 2024 saw a clear national decrease in murder rates to a multi‑year low, roughly 5–5.6 per 100,000, while city experiences varied widely—some cities falling sharply, others remaining far above the national average and skewing perceptions [1] [2] [3]. Any comparative claim must specify the metric (national FBI rate vs. city‑sample average), the cities included, and the reporting period. For precise local comparisons, consult jurisdictional reports and the FBI’s final Unified Crime Report figures, because aggregated summaries can conceal important methodological differences that drive divergent headline numbers [5] [1].