Are there documented cases in 2025 of U.S. citizens detained at the border or mistaken for noncitizens?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Multiple news investigations, lawsuits and government statements in 2025 document U.S. citizens being stopped, arrested or briefly detained by immigration agents; local reporting and reviews cite at least dozens of such cases in cities like Los Angeles and Chicago [1] [2]. Federal officials deny systemic deportation of citizens while members of Congress and watchdogs have demanded investigations into rising incidents and poor recordkeeping [3] [4].
1. What reporters and watchdogs have found: documented citizen detentions
Local and national outlets have documented numerous episodes in 2025 where people who are U.S. citizens were stopped, arrested or held by Border Patrol or ICE during immigration operations. A Capital & Main review and related reporting found at least nine citizens detained during enforcement actions in Los Angeles after June 6, 2025, and videos show citizens being tackled and held [1]. PolitiFact and other reviews report “numerous U.S. citizens” detained in and around Chicago during enforcement sweeps such as Operation Midway Blitz and note lawsuits and agency statements corroborating many incidents [2].
2. Federal denials and competing official narratives
DHS has pushed back against some reporting, issuing statements that ICE “does not deport U.S. citizens” and disputing specific accounts—arguing that enforcement actions were targeted and that when citizenship is verified, individuals are released [3]. DHS materials also include case-specific rebuttals and a “100 Days” fact-checking effort that describes episodes where citizenship was later confirmed and people released [5] [3]. These official denials exist alongside media reporting and legal filings documenting contrary episodes [1] [2].
3. Lawmakers and advocates say the incidents are widespread enough to merit probes
Members of Congress led by Rep. Dan Goldman and Sen. Elizabeth Warren demanded investigations into ICE practices after reports that U.S. citizens were being wrongfully detained or even deported, calling the pattern “alarming” and warning that poor agency recordkeeping obscures the full scope [4]. That demand reflects concern from oversight figures that citizens are becoming “increasingly vulnerable” under aggressive enforcement in 2025 [4].
4. How reporting and data paint different pictures
Investigations and data analyses show two overlapping trends: an overall surge in immigration enforcement and specific documented citizen detentions. ICE data reviewed by outlets show rising detention counts — ICE detention populations climbed sharply in 2025 — while reporters found many detained people had no criminal records [6] [7]. Meanwhile, NGOs and journalists have compiled video, lawsuits and local reporting that identify individual citizen detentions even as DHS emphasizes procedures to avoid arresting citizens [1] [6] [3].
5. What’s driving the confusion and mistakes
Experts and reporting point to rapid expansion of enforcement operations, data mismatches across government systems, and uneven field practices as drivers of wrongful stops and detentions. Congressional letters note ICE’s poor recordkeeping on citizenship flags; federal data systems and verification processes have produced false positives in related areas such as voter roll checks and SAVE system debates, illustrating how administrative errors can wrongly label people as noncitizens [4] [8] [9]. The Trump administration’s push for aggressive arrests and deportations — and a steep increase in detainee numbers — creates incentives for faster operations that oversight critics say increase error risk [7].
6. Legal and human consequences reported so far
Reporting documents civil litigation, internal investigations and community trauma linked to these detentions: journalists and local outlets have chronicled citizens who say they were wrongly held, sometimes for hours or days, and families who suffered disruption; politicians have sought answers about whether citizens were placed into removal proceedings [1] [2] [4]. Reuters and The Guardian contextualize this within large increases in detention and deportation volumes in 2025, which transform what had been considered rare errors into a pattern that triggers oversight demands [7] [10].
7. Limits of current reporting and unanswered questions
Available sources document many individual cases and oversight requests, but they also show disagreement: DHS disputes some reports and says the agency releases citizens once status is confirmed [3] [5]. Sources do not provide a definitive, agency-verified national count of how many U.S. citizens were detained, arrested or placed in removal proceedings in 2025; congressional requests explicitly ask DHS to produce those numbers because “the full scope remains unclear” [4]. For a complete tally, readers should watch for DHS briefings or inspector-general reports that respond to congressional inquiries [4].
8. Bottom line for readers
Multiple independent reporters, local video evidence and watchdog reviews show documented 2025 incidents where U.S. citizens were detained by immigration agents, while DHS disputes some accounts and emphasizes procedural safeguards and case-by-case explanations [1] [3] [2]. The competing narratives — rising enforcement volume versus official denials and the acknowledged gaps in agency recordkeeping — make independent oversight and clearer public data essential to resolve how systemic the problem has become [7] [4].