Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What accusations have been made about Alan Dershowitz and in which years were they reported?
Executive summary
Alan Dershowitz has been the subject of repeated public accusations primarily tied to his association with Jeffrey Epstein: most prominently, Virginia Giuffre accused him of sexual contact beginning when she was a minor (first publicly reported in 2014 and then resurfacing in 2018 filings and 2019 litigation), and those claims factored in lawsuits and settlements reported through 2022–2024 (notably a 2022 joint statement and reporting on unsealed 2024 deposition material) [1] [2] [3]. Reporting across outlets documents additional scrutiny about his role in Epstein’s legal defense and public statements defending Epstein’s plea deal [4] [5].
1. The Giuffre sexual‑abuse accusation and its timeline
Virginia Giuffre first publicly accused Dershowitz of having sex with her while she was trafficked by Jeffrey Epstein in filings that appear in coverage going back to 2014; those allegations were highlighted again by Miami Herald reporting in 2018 and led to defamation litigation in 2019, culminating in a 2022 joint statement in which Giuffre said she “may have made a mistake” and the parties dismissed litigation with no payment [1] [2]. In January 2024 Business Insider reported on newly unsealed deposition material in which Giuffre detailed alleged encounters she said involved Dershowitz when she was between 17 and 18, and described multiple settings including a plane and Epstein’s home [3].
2. Litigation: defamation suits, countersuits, and settlement reporting
After the accusations resurfaced in 2018, Giuffre sued Dershowitz for defamation in April 2019 and Dershowitz countersued in November 2019; those legal fights were widely reported and ultimately ended with a non‑monetary settlement and dismissal in November 2022, when Giuffre issued a joint statement acknowledging she “may have made a mistake” in identifying him [1] [2]. Reporting notes that David Boies was involved in related litigation and that the long dispute included motions over document sealing and disputes over filings [6] [1].
3. Unsealed documents and renewed media attention in 2024
Multiple outlets covered a tranche of unsealed Epstein‑related documents in early January 2024 that reawakened public focus on names tied to Epstein; Business Insider and The Independent described details from those filings and Dershowitz’s public response, including his insistence that documents would exonerate him and his posting of extended video defenses after the unsealing [3] [7]. Those pieces show the way unsealing drove new rounds of coverage even after the 2022 litigation resolution [3] [7].
4. Broader criticism about Epstein defense and public statements
Beyond the direct Giuffre allegation, outlets have reported criticism of Dershowitz’s role in securing Epstein’s 2008 plea deal and his public defenses of Epstein and of legal technicalities—coverage that framed those actions as part of why Dershowitz has been a focus of scrutiny [4] [5]. This criticism is separate from, but related to, the criminal‑allegation reporting because it concerns his professional ties to Epstein and public commentary about the case [4] [5].
5. Contradictory claims, denials, and limitations in the record
Dershowitz has repeatedly and forcefully denied having sexual contact with Giuffre and has sought unsealing of documents to clear his name; reporting quotes him disputing the accusations and calling for transparency [3] [7]. Conversely, Giuffre’s own later statement that she “may have made a mistake” complicates the record and was reported as part of the 2022 settlement coverage [2] [1]. Available sources do not mention third‑party criminal convictions against Dershowitz arising from these specific accusations (not found in current reporting).
6. Recent and ancillary reporting — emails and social coverage (2024–2025)
Coverage in late 2024 and 2025 continued to note documents and communications around Epstein and Dershowitz: outlets reported new emails released by Congress in 2025 that captured Epstein’s private criticisms of Dershowitz, and social‑media fact‑checks in November 2025 addressed other controversial headlines attributed to Dershowitz [8] [9]. These items show persistent interest in Dershowitz’s public persona beyond the core Giuffre allegations [8] [9].
Conclusion — what the sources show and what they don’t
The dominant accusations documented in the available reporting concern Virginia Giuffre’s claims (first visible in 2014 filings, amplified in 2018 reporting, litigated in 2019, and publicly addressed in the 2022 settlement), with renewed attention when documents were unsealed in 2024; parallel coverage criticizes his role in Epstein’s 2008 plea and his public defenses of Epstein [1] [2] [3] [4]. Available sources do not mention a criminal conviction of Dershowitz related to these accusations and report a mixture of denials, litigation, partial retractions or uncertainty from Giuffre, and continued media debate [2] [3].