Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What were annual deportation totals by fiscal year for the Trump, Biden, and Obama administrations?
Executive summary
DHS and independent analysts show wide variation by year and agency: ICE reported about 142,580 ICE removals in FY2023 and Reuters/ICE reported roughly 271,000 total deportations in FY2024, while Migration Policy estimates roughly 1.1 million deportations from FY2021 through Feb 2024 and that Trump-era deportations totaled about 1.5 million over his four years [1] [2] [3]. Available sources do not provide a single consistent, administration-level annual table that neatly lists “Trump vs. Biden vs. Obama” totals without combining ICE removals, CBP returns/expulsions, and Title 42 expulsions [4] [3].
1. What the official numbers measure — removals, returns, expulsions
The Department of Homeland Security and ICE publish separate tallies for “removals” (ICE-ordered departures), “returns/expulsions” (often CBP operational returns at the border), and Title 42 expulsions used during the pandemic; combining those produces higher “deportation” totals than ICE interior removals alone. The DHS Office of Homeland Security Statistics compiles removals and returns into monthly and annual tables [4], while ICE’s ERO reports focus on ICE removals and note when their dashboards exclude CBP returns and Title 42 expulsions [5] [1].
2. Trump-era (FY2017–FY2020) — scale and composition
Analysts place Trump-era totals at roughly 1.5 million deportations over his four-year term when counting removals and returns together; Migration Policy uses DHS and CBP datasets to conclude Trump’s four years saw about 1.5 million deportations [3]. ICE’s FY2019 single-year count of removals was about 267,000, a figure Migration Policy and Reuters reference in contextual comparisons [3] [2]. Note: official DHS Yearbook tables going back to 2019 are available for granular yearly figures but must be combined carefully across agencies [6].
3. Biden-era (FY2021–present) — rapid rise and shifting mix
Reporting shows a sharp rise in total deportations during the Biden administration: Reuters and BBC cite ICE’s annual report indicating about 271,000 deportations in FY2024 — the highest since 2014 and higher than any single Trump-year total [2] [7]. Migration Policy calculates roughly 1.1 million deportations from FY2021 through February 2024, putting Biden on pace to match Trump’s four-year total, while emphasizing that many of those were voluntary returns or border expulsions rather than interior ICE removals [3]. ICE’s FY2023 report separately states ICE ERO conducted 142,580 removals and that, including Title 42 expulsions and other movements, more than one million individuals were removed or expelled overall that year [1].
4. Obama-era (FY2009–FY2016) — higher ICE interior removals over time
Migration Policy and DHS data indicate higher interior removals in the Obama years relative to later years: analysts note an average of about 155,000 ICE removals per year in FY2009–2016, a higher interior-enforcement level than in subsequent years when policy and resource focus shifted toward the border [8]. DHS historical tables (Yearbook, Table 39) provide long-run removals/returns through 2019 for granular annual tallies, but combining across agencies and definitions is necessary to create administration-level summaries [6].
5. Why different outlets report different totals — methodology matters
Discrepancies arise because outlets and researchers choose different definitions: some sum ICE removals plus CBP returns and Title 42 expulsions to produce “total deportations/repatriations” (figures cited by Reuters, BBC and Migration Policy) while others report ICE-only removals [2] [7] [3] [1]. ICE itself warns its ERO dashboard does not include CBP removals/returns and that data are revised until “locked” at fiscal year close [9] [5]. Migration Policy explicitly distinguishes removals from voluntary returns at the border and calls attention to the changing composition of enforcement [3].
6. What a clean comparison would require
A reliable, administration-by-administration comparison requires: (a) deciding whether to count ICE removals only or the broader DHS “removals + returns/expulsions” metric; (b) using DHS/OHSS persist dataset tables for consistency across years; and (c) documenting Title 42-era expulsions separately because they boosted totals in 2020–2023 [4] [6] [1]. Available sources do not present a single pre-compiled, administration-level table that uniformly applies one definition across Obama, Trump and Biden — analysts create summary numbers by assembling DHS, ICE and CBP datasets [3] [2].
7. Bottom line and where to go next
If you want year-by-year, administration-level totals, consult DHS OHSS Yearbook/Table 39 and the OHSS monthly tables for removals/returns and then decide whether to include CBP returns and Title 42 expulsions; Migration Policy and Reuters provide ready interpretations and headline aggregates [6] [4] [3] [2]. Be explicit about the definition you choose: ICE-only removals will yield different and typically lower totals than “removals + returns/expulsions” used in many recent news accounts [1] [3].