What is the current legal status of Ayman Soliman's ICE case?

1. A sudden revocation and detention ignited a legal fight — what happened in June–July 2025?

In early June 2025, U.S. authorities revoked Soliman’s asylum status, after which he was detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement and held at Butler County Jail while lacking lawful immigration status. His lawyers publicly argued the revocation followed his litigation against the federal government over alleged placement on the Terrorist Screening Database and suggested the move could be retaliatory; the government cited alleged material support links to organizations tied to the Muslim Brotherhood as the basis for termination. Local reporting documented court filings seeking bond and habeas relief and a flurry of emergency motions — these events framed the case as both a procedural immigration removal matter and a civil‑rights concern ^{[1] [5] [6]}.

2. Courts intervened briefly — restraining orders, bond fights, and jurisdiction claims in July 2025

Throughout July 2025, Soliman’s legal team secured at least one Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) blocking his transfer out of Ohio pending bond proceedings; attorneys simultaneously sought custody redetermination and habeas review to challenge removal risk to Egypt. A federal judge issued an order restricting DHS movement of Soliman but also ruled limits on jurisdiction for granting bond in at least one filing, prompting plans to appeal that jurisdictional ruling. The July litigation centered on preventing removal, obtaining bond, and forcing administrative and judicial review, creating multiple procedural tracks: immigration court custody/bond hearings, federal habeas litigation, and administrative USCIS proceedings on asylum termination ^{[7] [8] [2]}.

3. Competing narratives: national-security rationale vs. advocates’ claims of overreach

Government filings alleged associations amounting to “material support” tied to groups the administration considered problematic, which officials used to justify asylum termination. Soliman’s counsel, civil‑liberties groups, and local officials countered that the connections were tenuous or mischaracterized and posited that the action functioned as punitive or discriminatory enforcement against a prominent imam and community leader. Reporting therefore split into a national‑security framing by authorities and a civil‑rights framing by advocates, each using the same factual milestones—revocation, detention, court motions—to argue divergent legal and policy implications ^{[5] [6]}.

4. Timeline confusion and the pivotal September 2025 turn reported by multiple outlets

Initial mid‑summer coverage documented active detention and upcoming hearings scheduled in July and August, but later reporting in September 2025 indicates a decisive change: Soliman was released from ICE custody on or around September 19, 2025, his deportation case was reportedly dropped, and USCIS reportedly reinstated his asylum status. These September accounts depict a reversal of the mid‑summer posture and show the litigation and public pressure potentially producing relief. The September reports change the factual status from detained respondent to released individual with restored immigration protections, illustrating how immigration litigation can yield abrupt status reversals ^{[3] [4]}.

5. What remains unsettled: appeals, records, and broader community concerns

Even after reported release and reinstatement in September 2025, questions remain: whether administrative or criminal records fully reflect the reinstatement, whether the government will appeal any judicial determinations, and whether parallel or future enforcement actions might arise from unresolved screening database issues. Community leaders and elected officials emphasized due‑process and fair treatment, while national‑security stakeholders may view the outcome as an incomplete resolution pending further review of alleged affiliations. The case therefore remains instructive for federal immigration practice, oversight of watchlist procedures, and community‑government trust issues ^{[1] [3]}.

6. Bottom line for the legal status as of the latest reporting and what to watch next

As of mid‑July 2025 the legal status was detainee with asylum revoked and active federal filings; by mid‑September 2025 multiple outlets reported Soliman’s release and reinstatement of asylum protections, with the deportation case dropped. Observers should monitor court dockets for official orders, USCIS administrative notices for asylum reinstatement, and any appeals by the government. The credible thread across sources is that Soliman’s status changed from detained and facing removal to released with immigration relief reported in September 2025, but formal, docketed orders will be the definitive record to confirm permanence ^{[2] [3] [4]}.