Are ICE agents arresting US citizens.
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Available reporting shows multiple, documented incidents in 2025 where federal immigration agents detained people later identified as U.S. citizens — including high-profile cases in Minneapolis and Chicago — even as DHS and ICE publicly insist they do not target citizens (examples: MPR, CNN, Washington Post; DHS statement) [1] [2] [3] [4].
1. What the reporting actually documents: citizen detentions in 2025
Local and national outlets have published specific cases in which people later identified as U.S. citizens were handcuffed, held or transported by ICE or federal agents: MPR reported an American tackled and arrested in Minneapolis (MPR) and CNN documented a Minneapolis lunch‑break detention where the man repeatedly asserted his citizenship as agents took him to a federal facility [1] [2]. The Washington Post and other outlets have chronicled similar arrests during large enforcement operations in Chicago and elsewhere [3].
2. Federal position: DHS and ICE deny systemic citizen arrests
The Department of Homeland Security issued a public rebuttal saying “ICE does not arrest or detain U.S. [citizens]” and framed reported incidents as exceptions — for example, arrests tied to obstruction or assault of officers — while insisting its officers are trained to determine status before enforcement [4]. ICE’s own statistics pages emphasize that Enforcement and Removal Operations targets “aliens” and say the agency uses intelligence‑driven, targeted operations [5].
3. Numbers and scale: mass arrests but unclear citizen share
Independent trackers and reporting show a sharp rise in ICE activity in 2025 — arrests counted in the tens of thousands monthly and daily arrest averages in the hundreds to over a thousand in places and periods of intensified operations (Prison Policy, Stateline, TRAC) — but the public datasets do not clearly quantify how many U.S. citizens were detained overall, and major databases focus on non‑citizen arrests or total bookings rather than verified misidentifications of citizenship [6] [7] [8].
4. How citizen detentions happen, per reporting and advocates
Reporting and advocacy accounts indicate several pathways: ICE executing old removal orders discovered at interviews, arrests during large community raids where agents rely on appearance or location, and incidents where agents detain bystanders or observers who approach enforcement activity [9] [6] [10]. Gateway Pundit frames some of these accounts as legally complex and rare, noting arrests tied to preexisting removal orders surfaced at USCIS interviews [9]. Local reporting captured cases of observers and residents detained while documenting ICE activity [10].
5. Legal and political context: aggressive enforcement and pushback
Multiple sources place the incidents inside a broader surge of enforcement under the administration: increased community raids, goals for large daily arrest numbers, and widespread use of local jails to funnel people into immigration processing [6] [7]. That intensification has triggered political backlash — governors and city officials demanded reviews of federal arrests and DHS leadership faced congressional questioning after high‑profile citizen detentions [2] [3].
6. Conflicting narratives and motivations to watch
There are competing frames: DHS says reports are false or misleading and emphasizes training and exceptions for criminal obstruction [4]; journalists and local officials document concrete cases of detained citizens and call for reviews [1] [2] [3]. Advocacy organizations and trackers focus on systemic trends — rising non‑citizen arrests and the use of local jails — arguing policy choices make misidentifications more likely [6] [7]. Each source has its implicit agendas: DHS defends agency practices; watchdogs emphasize civil‑liberties harms; local outlets prioritize eyewitness accounts and municipal oversight.
7. What’s missing or unresolved in current reporting
Available sources do not provide a comprehensive, government‑verified count of how many U.S. citizens have been detained by ICE in 2025, nor a systematic breakdown of causes (administrative errors, execution of old removal orders, confrontations, or arrests for unrelated criminal conduct) [5] [8]. DHS statements deny policy to detain citizens but do not reconcile that claim with the incident reporting cited by multiple news organizations [4] [1] [2].
8. Practical takeaway for readers
Documented incidents show U.S. citizens have been detained by federal immigration agents in 2025 in multiple locales; DHS denies systemic targeting of citizens while independent reporting and local officials call for investigations and transparency [1] [2] [4]. Readers seeking certainty should watch for agency disclosures, court filings, or consolidated datasets that explicitly track misidentified‑citizen detentions — those materials are not present in the current reporting corpus (not found in current reporting).