How do Obama-era deportation totals compare to those under Trump and Biden?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Obama’s eight-year tenure carried the largest official total of removals in recent decades: multiple sources report roughly 2.7–3.2 million formal deportations during 2009–2016 or, when counting all “repatriations/returns,” totals above 5 million [1] [2]. By contrast, reporting shows Trump’s first term removals around 1.2–2.1 million depending on what’s counted, and Biden-era repatriations/removals through 2024/early 2025 are variously reported as higher than Trump’s and in the millions — roughly 4.4–4.7 million by some tallies — though definitions (removals vs. returns vs. expulsions) differ across sources [2] [3] [4].
1. How the headline totals are being counted — apples, oranges, and labels
Different outlets and analysts use different definitions: “removals” or “deportations” often means formal DHS removal orders executed; “returns” or “repatriations” can include voluntary departures, expulsions under public-health rules (Title 42), and turnbacks at the border. The Migration Policy Institute piece emphasizes that under Obama most deportations were returns and that counting methods shifted over time [5]. The Independent and other outlets explicitly warn that totals combining removals and returns produce much larger figures than removal-order counts [2].
2. The Obama-era baseline: the largest formal totals in recent decades
Multiple fact-checking and data-aggregation reports conclude that Obama’s administration oversaw the largest formal totals over an eight-year span: Factchequeado’s analysis reports about 2.75 million deportations across 2009–2016 [1], while other summaries say Obama’s eight years produced over 3 million removal orders and more than 5 million total repatriations when returns and border turnbacks are included [2] [6]. Those higher sums are the basis for the frequent label “deporter-in-chief” applied to Obama in contemporary and retrospective coverage [6].
3. Trump’s record: lower monthly/removal rates in many counts
Reporting shows Trump’s first-term removals were generally lower than some Obama-era peaks, though context matters. Newsweek and The Globalist cite figures indicating Trump oversaw about 1.2–2.1 million removals in his first term depending on which counts are used; some analyses find his monthly removal rate in his second administration (2025 midyear) was below Obama’s peak monthly rates [4] [7]. TRAC’s analysis, written in early 2025, highlights that Trump’s stated claims about surpassing prior-year totals did not match the empirical DHS removal counts and that Trump’s average daily removal rate was roughly comparable to or slightly below Biden’s recent daily rate in certain comparisons [8] [9].
4. Biden-era totals: large repatriations but contested framing
Several outlets report very large Biden-era repatriation totals — The Independent cites roughly 4.7 million repatriations through November 2024, and Anadolu/AA cites 4.4 million for 2021–2022 — framing Biden as a “returner-in-chief” [2] [3]. Migration Policy notes that after Title 42 ended, Biden ramped up deportations under standard procedures, but it also stresses that diplomatic negotiations and country acceptances affected the ability to repatriate people [5]. Analysts caution that counting expulsions, returns, and formal removals together inflates comparisons across presidencies unless the same categories are used [5] [2].
5. Why year-by-year or daily-rate comparisons matter
Simple cumulative totals over whole presidencies obscure timing: Obama’s highest daily rates occurred in specific years (e.g., FY2013) and then fell [1]. TRAC emphasizes apples-to-apples comparisons using average daily rates for fiscal-year windows — finding Trump’s daily rate in early FY2025 around one percent below Biden’s recent daily rate, illustrating how short-term tempo shifts alter the impression given by cumulative totals [8] [9]. The Globalist similarly notes that, as of mid-2025, Trump deported fewer people per month than Obama did during his peak months [7].
6. Conflicting numbers and what that means for readers
Available reporting shows clear disagreement about exact magnitudes because sources mix removals, returns, expulsions, and voluntary departures. Factchequeado and The Conversation present analyses concluding Obama’s removals were the largest in recent decades [1] [6], while outlets summarizing DHS tallies for Biden report very large repatriation numbers that outpace prior single-term totals [2] [3]. TRAC’s contemporaneous data analysis pushes back on some political claims about Trump’s immediate performance, showing the need to check daily/ FY-based metrics against official DHS release timing [8] [9].
7. Bottom line and reporting caveats
The basic, evidence-backed bottom line from the supplied reporting: Obama’s administration produced the largest multi-year totals of removals in recent history by several measures [1] [2]. Biden-era repatriations through 2024 are reported as very high — in some counts higher than Trump’s and comparable to or exceeding earlier presidencies — but differences hinge on whether expulsions/returns are included [2] [3]. TRAC and other analysts warn that short-term claims by administrations about “surpassing” previous years frequently depend on which categories are counted and timing of DHS data releases [8] [9]. Available sources do not mention a single universally agreed numeric series that cleanly equates Obama, Trump, and Biden totals without these methodological caveats.