Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How did deportation numbers compare between the Trump and Obama administrations by year?
Executive summary
Available reporting shows Barack Obama’s administration recorded the highest multi-year totals in recent history (about 2.7–3.0 million removals across his two terms), while Donald Trump’s deportation totals and year‑by‑year performance are reported differently across outlets and time periods — some sources say roughly 1.2–2.1 million in his earlier term[1] depending on counting methods, and 2025 reporting finds Trump’s 2025 pace below Obama’s single-year peaks (e.g., Obama’s FY2014 ≈316,000 removals) [2] [3] [4]. Reporting disagrees on apples‑to‑apples annual comparisons because agencies count removals, border returns, “self‑deportations,” and fiscal vs. calendar years differently [5] [4].
1. How the official tallies are presented: removals vs. other returns
Journalists and analysts point out that DHS/ICE produce several overlapping metrics — “removals” or deportation orders, CBP return/expulsions at the border, and estimates of people who left without formal removal — and different articles use different mixes. For example, some pieces cite Obama-era totals of roughly 2.7–3.0 million removals over eight years, while others add border returns or self‑departures for larger aggregates; likewise, Trump‑era totals are reported as ~1.2 million (2017–2020) by some outlets but other writeups cite larger or smaller figures depending on whether they include self‑deportations or later fiscal‑year numbers [2] [4] [5].
2. Year‑by‑year peaks: Obama’s high single‑year totals
Multiple reports emphasize that Obama’s administration included some of the highest single‑year removal counts in recent decades. Factchequeado’s analysis and U.S. press reporting note Obama’s peak years (early in his presidency and particularly FY2013) produced higher monthly and annual averages than Trump’s 2025 pace — for example, Obama’s FY2014 removals were around 316,000, and Obama’s two‑term removals total roughly 2.7–2.9 million depending on the dataset [2] [3] [6].
3. Trump-era totals and 2025 trends: rising but not clearly surpassing Obama’s peaks
Coverage from Newsweek, CNN and others finds deportations rising under Trump’s later administration and into FY2025, with ICE deportations approaching or potentially surpassing levels not seen in a decade — e.g., reporting suggested ICE could surpass ~300,000 deportations in FY2025 if trends continued — but the same reporting also notes that Trump’s 2025 monthly averages remained below Obama’s highest monthly totals [5] [3] [6].
4. Disagreement among data trackers and independent analysts
Independent trackers and think‑tank analysts reach different conclusions when they rework DHS figures. TRAC and other analysts have challenged some public claims, reporting that early Trump claims of very large removal totals were overstated once apples‑to‑apples comparisons were made; TRAC estimated removals were substantially lower than some administration statements and that Trump’s average daily removal rate in some comparisons was near or below Biden’s at similar moments [7]. News outlets likewise report different multi‑million totals for different presidencies depending on method [5] [4].
5. What drives the differences — priorities and case selection
Reporting stresses that the mix of who is targeted changed across administrations: Obama’s later years emphasized convicted criminals in removals, which affected counts and public perceptions; Trump explicitly broadened priorities, and some outlets say enforcement under Trump focused less on criminal‑only criteria and more on wider removals, while critics point to resource and legal limits that constrained actual removals despite rhetoric [2] [4] [7].
6. Practical takeaway for year‑by‑year comparison
Available sources do not publish a single, reconciled year‑by‑year table in this set of documents; instead, they offer overlapping snapshots: Obama had the highest cumulative two‑term totals in recent decades and recorded higher monthly/annual peaks (e.g., FY2013/2014), while Trump’s later‑term and 2025 deportation activity rose dramatically but — by multiple reports — remained below Obama’s peak annual months and depends on whether analysts include removals, expulsions, or estimated self‑deportations [2] [5] [3] [4].
Limitations and next steps: the sources here differ in definitions (removals vs. returns vs. self‑deportations) and in the periods counted (fiscal vs. calendar years). If you want an exact, year‑by‑year table using one consistent metric (for example, DHS “removals” by fiscal year 2009–2025), I can compile that chart if you authorize me to extract the DHS/ICE fiscal‑year removals series from the underlying DHS reports referenced in these articles — that will produce the cleanest apples‑to‑apples comparison (available sources do not yet provide a single reconciled table in this collection) [2] [5] [7].