How many fatal use‑of‑force incidents involving ICE and CBP were documented from 2006 to 2015?
Executive summary
A precise tally of fatal use‑of‑force incidents involving Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) from 2006 through 2015 is not provided in the documents supplied; the available sources instead offer partial datasets, investigative retrospectives, and advocacy compilations that cover different timeframes and definitions of “use of force,” so a definitive count cannot be stated from this reporting alone [1] [2] [3]. The record that is available indicates systemic gaps in public documentation and differing methodologies that make cross‑source aggregation fraught without primary DHS/DOJ release or an independent dataset covering that exact period [4] [2].
1. What the user is actually asking — and why it matters
The query seeks a specific numeric count of fatal use‑of‑force incidents by two federal agencies over a ten‑year window; that requires consistent, incident‑level public records and an agreed definition of “fatal use‑of‑force” (for example, whether vehicle strikes, in‑custody deaths, and shootings are all included) — criteria that the available sources do not uniformly provide [4] [1]. The distinction matters because CBP’s own public reporting emphasizes incidents and assaults (counted in specific ways, e.g., one incident can involve multiple subjects) rather than a clean annual fatality log, and investigative journalism projects have produced partial but non‑overlapping catalogs [5] [1] [3].
2. What the government sources show (and do not show)
CBP’s official pages explain how CBP tallies “uses of force” and assaults and provide contextual statistics — for example, Border Patrol cites thousands of assaults since 2006 — but CBP’s public-facing pages do not publish an accessible, agency‑wide list of fatal use‑of‑force incidents for 2006–2015 in the material provided here [1] [5]. Independent oversight and policy digests compiled by Just Security collect DHS/DOJ/CBP policy changes and Inspector General work but focus on policies and reviews rather than enumerating historical fatalities for that decade [4].
3. What investigative projects and watchdogs have compiled
News investigations and open‑source projects have cataloged shootings and other deadly incidents, but their timeframes and methods vary. The Trace documented 59 ICE shootings between 2015 and 2021, a post‑2015 window that does not help count 2006–2015 fatalities [2]. The ICE List Wiki is an advocacy‑driven, crowdsourced archive intended to record incidents comprehensively, but it is a secondary compilation that must be cross‑checked against primary records and is not presented here as a definitive federal count [3].
4. Why a reliable number is elusive
Multiple causes account for the absence of a single, authoritative number in these sources: federal reporting practices differ across ICE and CBP, investigations are routed variably (sometimes to local agencies), deaths may be classified differently (in‑custody death, vehicle collision, shooting), and independent datasets begin or end at different years — all of which the available reporting documents and watchdog coverage reflect [2] [4]. Journalists and legal experts in the record point out that oversight gaps and inconsistent disclosure have left the public without a comprehensive historical tally [2] [6].
5. Reasonable next steps for verification
To produce a verifiable count for 2006–2015 would require assembling incident‑level records from DHS (ICE and CBP use‑of‑force logs), DOJ/Inspector General reports, state investigative files where jurisdiction was transferred, and vetted independent compilations such as The Trace or FOIA‑based datasets like ICE List Wiki — then reconciling duplicates and definitions [2] [3] [4]. The existing sources make clear that without that primary‑record reconciliation, any firm numeric claim would be speculative [4] [2].
---
"Given the documents provided, a definitive number of fatal use‑of‑force incidents involving ICE and CBP from 2006 through 2015 cannot be established; the sources here document methodology, later time periods, and advocacy compilations rather than a single, authoritative count for that decade" [1] [2] [3].