Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How many I.C.E. arrests were American citizens
Executive summary
Reporting from ProPublica and multiple news outlets finds at least about 170 U.S. citizens have been arrested or detained by immigration agents since President Trump’s second-term inauguration; NPR and CBC cite that 170+ tally but note independent confirmation limits [1] [2]. ICE’s public statistics do not publish an explicit, consolidated count of citizen arrests, and Congress members and advocates say agency record‑keeping on citizenship is incomplete, leaving the full scope unclear [3] [4].
1. The headline number: “170+” — what it is and where it comes from
The frequently cited figure — “at least 170 U.S. citizens” arrested or detained since Trump reclaimed the presidency — originates from investigative reporting summarized by ProPublica and repeated in outlets such as NPR and CBC; those outlets also flag that they have not independently verified every case in the tally [1] [2]. Local and regional reporting (e.g., OPB, Louisiana Illuminator) has echoed the same ProPublica-based count while documenting individual citizen cases that underpin the total [5] [6].
2. What kinds of encounters are included in that tally
The reported 170+ figure encompasses a mix of situations: people identified as U.S. citizens who were detained during large immigration raids or workplace actions, individuals who said they were unjustly held despite presenting ID, and some cases where citizens were alleged to have obstructed officers and were arrested for that conduct [5] [2]. Reporting shows many headline cases include video or witness accounts of force during arrests — for example, an ICU nurse and other bystanders filmed confrontations that they say show agents using rough tactics [2].
3. ICE’s data and official transparency gaps
ICE’s public Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) statistics provide arrest breakdowns by country of citizenship and criminal history categories but do not publish a straightforward, verified national count of U.S. citizens arrested by immigration agents during 2025 operations in the way journalists have compiled [3]. Members of Congress and oversight advocates have demanded investigations and questioned whether ICE tracks how many U.S. citizens are stopped, arrested, detained or deported; they cite inconsistent field reporting and a directive to update citizenship data that may not be fully complied with [4].
4. Disagreement from DHS/ICE and competing narratives
The Department of Homeland Security has pushed back in some reporting, telling ProPublica and others that agents do not racially profile or target Americans and that the agency “doesn’t arrest US citizens for immigration enforcement” — an official stance that conflicts with documented cases and the journalistic tally [5]. ICE and DHS frame operations as focused on “criminal illegal aliens” and public‑safety priorities, while reporters and advocates document examples where agents detained people who were U.S. citizens or where citizenship was ignored during enforcement actions [2] [7].
5. Broader context on enforcement scale and treatment claims
The citizen‑detention stories sit inside a much larger surge in immigration arrests and detentions: data trackers report the administration has overseen tens of thousands of arrests (e.g., 138,068 arrests through late July in one analysis) and a dramatic increase in detention populations and budgets, which critics say strains oversight and raises the risk of wrongful detentions [8] [9]. Human-rights advocates and international outlets describe aggressive tactics, alleging arbitrary arrests and poor detention conditions, and note that many people held by ICE have no criminal conviction, further complicating claims that enforcement targets only “criminals” [10] [9].
6. What the reporting does not (yet) establish
Available sources do not provide a complete, independently verified national database of U.S. citizen arrests by ICE with final dispositions; NPR explicitly notes it has not independently confirmed ProPublica’s tally, and ICE’s public stats do not supply a single consolidated citizen-arrest count [1] [3]. The Government Accountability Office’s earlier work (2015–2020) found instances of deported citizens, but up‑to‑date, agency‑verified totals for 2025 remain unavailable in the cited reporting [11].
7. Takeaways and why the gap matters
Journalistic investigations and congressional inquiries converge on a clear policy issue: journalists and lawmakers document dozens to hundreds of citizen detentions and say ICE record‑keeping and transparency are inadequate, while ICE/DHS emphasize enforcement priorities and deny systemic targeting — a factual disagreement that makes independent verification crucial [4] [5]. Until ICE publishes a clear, audited accounting of stops, arrests and outcomes by claimed citizenship, the “at least 170” figure represents the best publicly reported tally but not an undisputed official total [1] [2].