Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
How many Israelis were actually arrested in the US on September 11, 2001?
Executive Summary
Five Israeli nationals were arrested in a single, widely reported incident on September 11, 2001; that episode involved a van, five men employed by Urban Moving Systems, and suspicions raised by witnesses and investigators [1]. In the days and weeks after 9/11 a substantially larger number of Israeli citizens were detained by U.S. authorities on immigration or visa violations — reporting at the time cited around 60 detained through November 2001 and some tallies pushing toward 140 for the year — but federal officials said those cases were immigration matters, not terrorism prosecutions [2] [3]. The narrow factual claim — “How many Israelis were arrested on September 11, 2001?” — is best answered by distinguishing the single five-person arrest that day from the broader post-9/11 detentions that followed.
1. The photograph, the van, and five men: why this arrest became the headline
On September 11, 2001 a New Jersey witness reported suspicious behavior that led police to stop a van and arrest five Israeli men identified as Sivan Kurzberg, Paul Kurzberg, Yaron Shmuel (Shimuel), Oded Ellner, and Omer Marmari; officers found cash, foreign passports, and a box cutter and the men were photographed on that morning taking pictures of the World Trade Center, which amplified public alarm [1]. The men worked for Urban Moving Systems, which investigators later examined; the immediate arrest tied directly to eyewitness reports and visible behavior at the scene, making this a discrete, well-documented law-enforcement action that occurred on the day of the attacks [1]. This five-person arrest is the specific event most often invoked when people ask “How many Israelis were arrested on 9/11?” [1].
2. The wider sweep: dozens detained in the chaotic weeks after 9/11
Reporting from late 2001 documents that many more Israeli nationals were detained in the weeks following the attacks, primarily on immigration or visa violations rather than terrorism charges; contemporary accounts cite at least 60 Israelis held by November and suggest a figure approaching 140 across 2001, reflecting a broad enforcement response to suspicious visas and work practices among young Israelis traveling after military service [2] [3]. Federal and Israeli officials told reporters these were largely immigration matters tied to working on tourist visas, with no public evidence linking the detainees to the terrorist plot. The post-9/11 detention numbers reflect an enforcement surge across many communities, not a single, coordinated criminal case against Israelis for planning the attacks [2].
3. What investigators concluded: no proven foreknowledge by the five, mixed reporting on intelligence links
FBI inquiries into the five men arrested on September 11 produced no publicly released evidence proving they had foreknowledge of the attacks; the agency investigated their statements, photographs, and the Urban Moving Systems connection, and later public summaries and reporting stopped short of showing operational ties to the hijackers [1] [4]. Some articles and later narratives suggested links to Israeli intelligence or called the moving company a possible front, but the FBI publicly reported no conclusive proof of advance knowledge of 9/11 by the five arrested, a point that federal sources repeatedly emphasized even as uncertainty and rumors persisted [4] [1]. Investigative language, not conspiracy, dominated official conclusions.
4. How this story became a magnet for conspiracy theories and contested narratives
The dramatic image of smiling or apparently celebratory men photographing the towers and the existence of an Israeli-run moving company in proximity to the attacks created fertile ground for alternative narratives and conspiracy theories; journalists and online pages later dubbed the group the “dancing Israelis,” and some accounts amplified unverified intelligence-sourcing claims [5] [4]. Different outlets emphasized different elements: eyewitness descriptions, unusual behavior, or alleged intelligence links; others stressed lack of forensic evidence or FBI findings clearing the men of foreknowledge. The combination of an emotionally charged event, visible photos, and partial government disclosure created space for competing accounts that persist in public discourse [5] [4].
5. Why reportage varies and what authoritative sources omit or downplay
Contemporary government reviews of post-9/11 detentions focused on immigration-enforcement patterns and national-security screening and did not catalog all nationalities or single-day arrests in a way that neatly answers the casual question about “how many Israelis were arrested on 9/11”; departmental reports on detainee treatment and the DOJ review emphasize process over headline counts [6] [7]. Media pieces, investigative summaries, and later retrospectives vary in emphasis and sometimes conflate the single-day five-person arrest with the broader wave of detentions; that conflation is the primary source of public confusion around raw numbers [6] [3].
6. Bottom line: a precise answer with nuance and context
The precise, verifiable fact is that five Israeli nationals were arrested on September 11, 2001 in a single, widely reported incident involving a van and eyewitnesss’ suspicions [1]. In the subsequent weeks and months the U.S. detained dozens of other Israeli nationals on immigration-related grounds — reporting cited around 60 by late November 2001 and broader counts approaching 140 for the year — but those were separate administrative or immigration actions rather than prosecutions directly tied to the 9/11 plot [2] [3]. Answering the question accurately requires separating the immediate five-person arrest from the larger post-attack detentions; mixing them produces misleading conclusions.