Of the 70 US citizens accidentally deported by ICE, how many remain outside the US?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
The count of "70 U.S. citizens deported by ICE" comes from government data analyzed by watchdog researchers, but none of the supplied reporting states how many of those 70 remain outside the United States today; that specific outcome is not reported in the sources provided [1]. Available sources make clear the record-keeping is incomplete and that some wrongly removed citizens have since been returned—but the supplied material does not enumerate current whereabouts for the 70 cases [1] [2].
1. Origin of the “70” figure and what it actually measures
The figure of 70 arises from analysis of federal enforcement data covering a specified period and was highlighted by advocates and watchdogs as evidence ICE removed U.S. citizens in error; the American Immigration Council summarizes findings that ICE arrested 674 potential U.S. citizens, detained 121, and deported 70 in the timeframe examined by TRAC and other analysts [1]. That 70 is a count of removals identified in the data, not a live-status roll call of where those people are today, and must be read as a snapshot produced from imperfect records [1].
2. Why the final locations of those 70 are not reported in the sources
The underlying problem is a data gap: TRAC and other investigators found ICE and CBP do not maintain sufficiently reliable citizenship-investigation records to fully track wrongful arrests and removals, meaning government datasets used to produce the 70 figure lack follow-up fields that would tell researchers whether deported U.S. citizens remained abroad or were subsequently returned [1]. Independent reporting and watchdog pieces repeatedly emphasize the messiness of tallying Americans detained or deported by immigration agents, reinforcing that comprehensive case-by-case outcomes are often missing from public records [3].
3. Evidence that some wrongly deported U.S. citizens were returned — but not a numerical reconciliation
Specific high-profile cases and litigation show the government has at times returned U.S. citizens wrongly removed and that courts have ordered returns or damages, proving return is possible and has occurred [2] [4]. However, these individual stories do not provide a systematic accounting of the fate of the 70 people counted in the TRAC/Government Accountability Office-style tallies, and none of the supplied sources supply a reconciled “returned vs. still abroad” breakdown for that cohort [2] [5].
4. Competing narratives and institutional incentives that shape the record
Advocacy groups and watchdogs emphasize undercounting and systemic error—TRAC’s broader finding that thousands were misidentified supports that view and underscores critics’ calls for better tracking [1]. Conversely, DHS and administration messaging have incentives to emphasize enforcement numbers and public-safety gains, sometimes releasing headline totals about removals without granular follow-up on erroneous deportations or returns, complicating independent verification [6]. That divergence of agendas helps explain why a clear follow-up statistic on the 70 is absent in publicly cited sources.
5. Direct answer and the limits of the record
Based solely on the supplied reporting, it is not possible to state how many of the 70 U.S. citizens identified as deported by ICE remain outside the United States today because the sources do not report that outcome and note that recordkeeping is insufficient to make that determination [1] [3]. Any definitive number would require case-level follow-up by investigators or a government accounting that the provided materials say does not exist publicly.