Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
What are the annual arrest numbers for human traffickers by ICE?
Executive summary
ICE’s Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) reports annual arrests of alleged human traffickers that vary year-to-year: notable figures include 1,437 arrests in FY2015 [1], 1,952 in FY2016 [2], 2,197 in FY2019 [3] [4] and 2,360 in FY2021 [5] [6]. Congressional and DHS reports show an even higher HSI arrest count of 2,610 for FY2023 in one compilation and 2,360–2,610 appear across sources for recent years [7] [5] [6].
1. How ICE/HSI publishes these numbers — official press releases and reports
ICE’s criminal investigative arm, Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), has routinely announced annual totals in agency press releases and feature pages: for example HSI said it arrested 1,437 people in FY2015 [1] and 1,952 in FY2016 [2]. HSI likewise announced a FY2019 total of 2,197 arrests and highlighted 1,024 human‑trafficking–nexus investigations that year [3] [4]. HSI’s figures are repeated across DHS materials and ICE press outreach [3] [4].
2. Variation across years — a pattern of fluctuation, not simple growth
The available reporting shows substantial year‑to‑year variation rather than a steady linear trend: FY2015 [8] [9], FY2016 [8] [10], FY2019 [11] [12], FY2020 (~1,746), FY2021 [11] [13] and FY2023 (reported as 2,610 in a congressional summary) are examples from different documents [1] [2] [3] [5] [7]. DHS’s Center for Countering Human Trafficking (CCHT) annual reporting shows arrests rose from 1,746 in FY2020 to 2,360 in FY2021 [5]. These fluctuations reflect changing investigative activity, priorities, and reporting conventions [3] [5].
3. What “arrests” likely include — different metrics and definitions
Reporting and fact‑checking show that counting arrests in trafficking investigations can mix different types of arrests. FactCheck noted that ICE‑HSI’s arrest totals can include individuals arrested in the course of trafficking investigations even if charged under other statutes, and that a breakdown by specific trafficking statutes can be much smaller than the headline arrest number [14]. ICE materials themselves sometimes couple arrests with investigations, indictments, and convictions in their summaries, which can obscure exactly which arrests were charged under federal trafficking statutes versus related offenses [4] [3].
4. Multiple data sources and occasional discrepancies
Different official publications do not always match perfectly. For example, an ICE/HSI press release and a DHS annual report both publish arrest totals for given fiscal years [3] [5], while a Congressional Research Service compilation cites 2,610 ICE/HSI arrests for FY2023 [7]. FactCheck has previously flagged social‑media charts that misrepresented ICE numbers by conflating or inflating figures, underscoring the need to use primary ICE/DHS releases and congressional summaries rather than third‑party infographics [14].
5. Contextual numbers — investigations, victims identified, and prosecutions
ICE/HSI reporting pairs arrests with other measures: FY2019 reporting notes 1,024 investigations, 1,113 indictments and 691 convictions along with 2,197 arrests and 428 victims identified [4]. DHS CCHT reporting for FY2021 linked 1,111 investigations to 2,360 arrests [5]. These adjacent metrics matter: arrests alone do not equal convictions, nor do they fully capture victim identification or long‑term outcomes [4] [5].
6. What the sources don’t tell us
Available sources do not provide a single, consistently defined annual time series from 2015–2024 that reconciles methodology changes, nor do they always break out how many arrests were charged under trafficking statutes versus related crimes; FactCheck drew attention to this gap when comparing counts by statute [14]. Detailed line‑by‑line methodology for how HSI compiles “arrests” is not fully spelled out across all cited documents [14] [4].
7. How to interpret the headline numbers — cautious takeaways
Use headline HSI arrest totals as indicators of enforcement activity, not as direct measures of trafficking prevalence or successful prosecutions: ICE/HSI often pairs arrests with investigations, indictments and victim‑assistance figures, and the composition of arrests (trafficking statute vs. ancillary offenses) can differ [3] [4] [14]. For FY2019 and FY2021 the most direct ICE/DHS figures are 2,197 and 2,360 arrests respectively [3] [5]; a congressional compilation lists 2,610 arrests for FY2023 [7].
If you want a single reconciled table for every fiscal year, those specific reconciled numbers are not provided across these documents; compiling such a table would require cross‑validation of ICE press releases, DHS CCHT reports, and congressional datasets to resolve definitional differences [14] [5] [7].