Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: What were the total ICE arrests in 2024?
Executive Summary
The clearest, directly reported figure across official ICE materials is that Enforcement and Removal Operations (ERO) conducted 113,431 administrative arrests in Fiscal Year 2024, and the agency also reports 32,608 criminal arrests attributed to Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), while ICE removed 271,484 noncitizens in FY2024 [1] [2]. Different reports frame those numbers differently — some emphasize ERO administrative arrests as the core “ICE arrests” metric, while others combine ERO and HSI activity or focus on removals rather than arrests, producing apparent variation in how totals are reported [1] [3]. This analysis extracts the key claims from the provided materials, compares the numbers and framing, highlights what the data do and do not show, and explains where common misunderstandings originate.
1. What the official claims actually say — a plain reading that cuts through shorthand
The ICE Fiscal Year 2024 Annual Report explicitly lists 113,431 administrative arrests by ERO and 32,608 criminal arrests by HSI, and separately reports 271,484 removals for FY2024; the Annual Report further breaks ERO arrests into 81,312 with criminal convictions or pending charges and 32,119 without [1]. The simple headline “ICE arrests” is imprecise because ICE is composed of multiple operational components with different authorities and reporting approaches: ERO primarily conducts civil immigration administrative arrests, while HSI conducts criminal arrests tied to investigations. The Annual Report uses those component-level tallies rather than a single consolidated “ICE arrests” line, which creates room for different summaries in news and advocacy reports [1] [3].
2. How journalists and analysts have presented those numbers — competing narratives and emphasis
News outlets and advocacy projects highlight different aspects: some coverage emphasizes the total removals [4] [5] as the most consequential outcome and notes the high share with criminal histories [6] [7], while other analyses focus on ERO’s administrative arrests to evaluate civil enforcement intensity. One explainer observing historical trends contrasted administrative-arrest totals over time, noting discrepancies between various trackers and DHS statements [1] [2]. Framing matters: citing 113,431 ERO arrests stresses civil immigration enforcement activity; combining ERO and HSI figures or pointing to removals frames enforcement as broader or more outcome-oriented. These choices reflect editorial priorities and different policy questions rather than contradictions in the source data itself [2] [3].
3. Where numbers diverge and why those divergences are not necessarily errors
Discrepancies in public discussion stem from differences between arrests and removals, and between administrative and criminal arrests. The Annual Report’s 113,431 figure is ERO administrative arrests; HSI’s 32,608 are criminal arrests tied to investigations; the 271,484 figure counts removals — people actually deported or otherwise removed — which is a different operational metric [1]. Some datasets and trackers report multi-year aggregates or restrict to “at-large” arrests versus arrests at the border or in custody, which changes totals. Therefore, apparent contradictions often reflect apples-to-oranges comparisons rather than faulty data. The ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations statistics provide granular breakdowns but do not always synthesize a single cross-component arrest total, which allows multiple defensible summaries depending on the question [3].
4. Who emphasizes what and what motivations may underlie different emphases
Advocates and critics who spotlight the 113,431 ERO arrests typically aim to document civil enforcement reach and the proportion involving noncitizens without criminal convictions; proponents of stricter enforcement and departmental briefings may emphasize removals and the share with criminal histories to spotlight public-safety rationales [1]. Media summaries that present the largest single headline number — the 271,484 removals — are responding to the magnitude of that outcome; explainers that compare multi-year arrest trends highlight accountability and policy change. The choice of metric therefore signals a perspective on what constitutes the most salient measure of enforcement activity, which readers should track when interpreting headlines [2] [8].
5. Bottom line answer and recommended reading to resolve confusion
If you ask “What were the total ICE arrests in 2024?” the most precise, source-backed answer is: ERO reported 113,431 administrative arrests in FY2024, and HSI reported 32,608 criminal arrests; ICE reported 271,484 removals in FY2024 — but there is no single consolidated ‘ICE arrests’ number beyond adding component tallies, and different outlets emphasize different metrics [1]. To avoid confusion, consult the ICE FY2024 Annual Report for component-level arrest figures and the ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations statistics for granular breakdowns; compare those with media summaries of removals to see how framing changes the story [3].