Keep Factually independent
Whether you agree or disagree with our analysis, these conversations matter for democracy. We don't take money from political groups - even a $5 donation helps us keep it that way.
Fact check: Can individuals with minor crimes or misdemeanors be deported by ICE?
Executive Summary
Federal enforcement data and investigative reporting from mid-2025 show that ICE is deporting people with minor offenses, misdemeanors, and even traffic infractions, contradicting repeated official statements that enforcement targets only the “worst of the worst.” Multiple analyses and internal documents indicate a substantial share of recent arrests and deportations involve individuals with no serious criminal convictions, and some months show dramatic increases in deportations for traffic-related violations [1] [2] [3]. Official ICE public releases emphasize serious crimes, but agency data and journalistic investigations present a different picture of enforcement priorities and outcomes [4] [5] [6].
1. Shocking Numbers: Thousands Deported for Low-Level Offenses — What the Data Shows
Investigative reports from August 2025 document that thousands of people deported this year had only minor offenses or traffic violations, with one series noting over 1,800 deportations for traffic infractions and monthly traffic-related removals more than tripling in recent months [1] [2]. Internal government documents obtained earlier in June 2025 show that over 75% of people booked into ICE custody since October had no criminal conviction beyond immigration or traffic matters, and fewer than 10% were convicted of serious violent crimes like murder or rape [3]. These figures indicate a divergence between public messaging and operational outcomes.
2. Agency Messaging vs. Internal Reality — How Public Statements Differ from Documents
ICE and Justice Department news releases routinely highlight arrests tied to human trafficking, child exploitation, narcotics, and other violent crimes, framing enforcement around high-threat individuals [4]. However, the internal government data and independent reporting reveal that the largest growth in detentions and deportations has been among those with no criminal records or only minor infractions, suggesting that public messaging does not fully reflect the composition of enforcement actions [3] [6]. The juxtaposition points to a gap between selective high-profile announcements and the day-to-day enforcement profile.
3. The Rise of Non‑Convicted Detainees — Civil vs. Criminal Distinctions Matter
Multiple September 2025 datasets show a clear increase in detentions of people without criminal convictions, with some reporting that non-convicted individuals became the largest group in detention and arrests rising by triple- and quadruple-digit percentages since the start of the administration’s second term [6] [5]. Immigration status violations are civil, not criminal, yet civil immigration enforcement can still lead to detention and removal. The data highlights that being undocumented or having minor traffic infractions is increasingly driving ICE arrests and deportations, not only convicted criminality [5].
4. Traffic Tickets, Weed Possession, and the ‘Minor Offense’ Category — A Closer Look
Reporting from August 2025 specifically itemizes deportations tied to low-level offenses such as traffic tickets and small-scale drug possession, with monthly traffic-related deportations surging to nearly 600 in a recent month [2] [1]. These categories often result in brief encounters with law enforcement that can trigger immigration checks. The scale of these removals signals that minor contacts with the criminal justice system are functioning as de facto immigration enforcement triggers, expanding the reach of removal beyond traditionally prioritized threats [2] [1].
5. Timeline and Trends — Rapid Increases and Policy Shifts Across 2025
Data points across June through September 2025 show consistent upward trends: internal documents from June establish the baseline that most detained lacked serious convictions [3], August investigations quantify thousands of minor-offense deportations [1] [2], and September analyses show non-convicted detainees growing to be the largest group, with percentage increases in arrests since the administration’s second term reaching into the triple digits [6] [5]. The timeline suggests a policy environment and enforcement practice producing rapid changes in who is being detained and deported.
6. Conflicting Agendas — Why Different Sources Emphasize Different Facts
Government press releases emphasize dangerous criminal removals to justify enforcement and highlight public safety impacts [4]. Investigative outlets and internal data emphasize the human and numeric scale of deportations for low-level or no criminality, framing the issue as a mismatch between rhetoric and practice [1] [2] [3]. Both vantage points are factual but selective: official statements focus on high-threat cases, while journalists and data releases illuminate aggregate patterns that include many low‑level removals, revealing differing institutional priorities and potential political agendas [4] [3].
7. Bottom Line and Unanswered Questions — What Remains to Be Clarified
Established facts through September 2025 show that ICE removals include substantial numbers of people with minor offenses or no convictions, and that enforcement patterns have shifted to increase such detentions and deportations [1] [6]. Remaining questions include the administrative policies driving prioritization changes, local law-enforcement cooperation practices that funnel traffic and low-level offenses into immigration checks, and the long-term effects on communities and legal processes. Further transparency in ICE data releases and policy memos would clarify whether these are intended policy goals or operational byproducts [5].