Can ICE detain US citizens by mistake in 2025?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Was this fact-check helpful?
1. Summary of the results
Based on the analyses provided, ICE can and does detain US citizens by mistake. Multiple documented cases demonstrate this concerning pattern:
- Elzon Lemus, a Hispanic US citizen, was stopped and detained by ICE agents without reasonable suspicion or probable cause, allegedly because he "looks like somebody we are looking for" [1] [2]
- Brian Gavidia was detained despite identifying himself as a US citizen [2]
- Leonardo Garcia Venegas and Jose Hermosillo were also wrongfully detained as US citizens [3]
The evidence shows that racial profiling appears to be a significant factor in these wrongful detentions, with Latino citizens being disproportionately targeted [2] [3]. The problem has become serious enough that Congress is considering legislation specifically designed to prevent ICE from detaining or deporting US citizens [3].
2. Missing context/alternative viewpoints
The original question lacks several important contextual elements:
- Scale and frequency: The analyses don't provide statistics on how often these mistakes occur relative to total ICE operations
- ICE's enforcement tactics: Nearly half of people currently in ICE custody have neither been convicted of nor charged with any crime [4], suggesting broader issues with detention practices
- Warrantless arrests: ICE conducts aggressive enforcement including warrantless arrests, as demonstrated in the case of Abel Orozco [4]
- Legal protections: Citizens have specific rights when encountering ICE, including the right to remain silent and request legal representation [5]
- Mistaken identity cases: Beyond citizenship errors, ICE also detains individuals based on mistaken identity, as alleged in the case of Victor Martinez [6]
Beneficiaries of different narratives:
- Immigration advocacy groups benefit from highlighting these cases to push for reform and increased oversight
- ICE and immigration enforcement agencies might benefit from downplaying these incidents to maintain public support for their operations
- Politicians supporting stricter immigration enforcement may benefit from minimizing attention to wrongful citizen detentions
3. Potential misinformation/bias in the original statement
The original question itself appears factually neutral and appropriate - it simply asks whether ICE can detain US citizens by mistake in 2025. However, potential areas of concern include:
- Framing as "mistake": While the question uses the term "mistake," the evidence suggests some detentions may involve deliberate racial profiling rather than innocent errors [1] [2]
- Missing systemic context: The question doesn't address whether this represents isolated incidents or a pattern of civil rights violations that has prompted congressional action [3]
- Temporal specificity: By asking specifically about 2025, the question might inadvertently suggest this is a new phenomenon, when the evidence shows it has been an ongoing issue requiring legislative intervention
The analyses consistently support that wrongful detention of US citizens by ICE is a documented reality, not merely a theoretical possibility.