What were the annual number and causes of death among ICE detainees from 2015 to 2024?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
ICE reported 12 deaths in its custody for fiscal year (FY) 2024, up from 4 in FY2023 and 3 in FY2022, and human-rights and public-health reviews identify medical neglect, suicide and COVID-19 as leading contributors to past detainee deaths; independent research documents 52 deaths from 2017–2021 and finds most were likely preventable [1] [2] [3]. Reporting on 2015–2024 annual totals is fragmented in available sources; ICE’s official Detainee Death Reporting page and academic reviews cover specific years and FY ranges but the provided results do not include a complete year-by-year table for 2015–2024 [4] [5].
1. What the official tallies show and their limits — ICE’s reporting regime
ICE maintains a Detainee Death Reporting page and says it notifies stakeholders and conducts internal reviews for every in-custody death; those pages are the formal source for annual counts but the dataset is not reproduced in full among the materials you provided, so a complete 2015–2024 year-by-year list is not available in current reporting [4]. The agency’s processes — 12‑hour reporting requirements and internal reviews by the Office of Professional Responsibility — are documented by ICE, but critics say those internal probes often fall short [4] [6].
2. Recent annual snapshots journalists and researchers cite
Multiple news outlets and research groups converge on one clear recent figure: ICE reported 12 deaths in FY2024, a sharp rise from the few deaths reported in the two prior years (4 in FY2023; 3 in FY2022) [1]. Independent tallies and press accounts also put FY2024 at 12 deaths and note the year represented a marked increase in fatalities compared with 2022–2023 [7] [1].
3. Independent investigations document causes across years
A multi‑organization report by the ACLU, Physicians for Human Rights and American Oversight reviewed 52 detainee deaths from 2017–2021 and concluded nearly all were preventable with adequate medical and mental‑health care; the report identifies medical neglect, missed diagnoses, delayed treatment and suicides as major causes or contributors [2] [8]. Academic case‑series work updating FY2018–2023 also examined medical vs. suicide deaths and tracked COVID‑19’s contribution to elevated mortality during the pandemic years [5].
4. Why year-to-year counts can be misleading
Advocates and researchers warn official counts understate the problem because ICE sometimes releases seriously ill detainees before they die, a practice that can remove cases from the “in‑custody” tally; the ACLU/PHR/American Oversight report and allied coverage describe this as a mechanism that reduces reported deaths and accountability [9] [6]. Reporting practices, fiscal‑year framing (FY runs Oct–Sep) and differences between ICE news releases and the Detainee Death Reporting page also create discrepancies in public tallies [10] [7].
5. Trends and context 2017–2024: pandemic and after
Available analyses show a COVID‑era spike in deaths tied to infection and suicide, with death rates and causes shifting as vaccines became available and detention populations changed; studies comparing FY2018–2020 with FY2021–2023 document these dynamics and include methodical reviews of when COVID‑19 was listed as a cause or contributor [5]. The 2017–2021 ACLU/PHR/American Oversight review found systemic failures in medical care across that interval [2].
6. Conflicting narratives and where sources disagree
ICE’s public stance emphasizes rule‑bound internal review and access to medical care; independent reports state those reviews repeatedly fail to interview witnesses, preserve evidence or identify systemic causes, framing many deaths as preventable [4] [6]. News organizations tally more recent deaths differently at times — for example, journalists and NGOs report FY2024’s 12 deaths consistently, but later-year tallies vary across outlets because ICE releases, news reports and independent counts diverge [1] [7].
7. What is not in the provided sources
A comprehensive, year‑by‑year numeric table listing the total number of deaths and the precise cause for each year from 2015 through 2024 is not present in the sources you supplied; therefore I cannot produce a fully sourced 2015–2024 table here. Available sources document specific fiscal‑year snapshots (notably FY2022–FY2024) and multi‑year analyses focused on 2017–2021 and FY2018–2023 but do not enumerate every single calendar year 2015–2024 with causes [2] [5] [1].
8. How to get the complete year-by-year breakdown
For a definitive, sourced year‑by‑year list and cause-of-death detail, consult ICE’s Detainee Death Reporting webpage (official counts and reports), cross‑check with ICE news releases, and pair those with independent reviews (ACLU/PHR/American Oversight, peer‑reviewed epidemiologic studies) to capture disputed cases and interpret causes; the ICE page and the ACLU/PHR report are central starting points in the documents you provided [4] [2].
Limitations: this analysis uses only the documents you gave; those documents document FY2022–FY2024 snapshots and multi‑year studies (2017–2021, FY2018–2023) but do not contain a complete, cited 2015–2024 year‑by‑year table of deaths and causes [2] [5] [4].