How do ICE detainee mortality rates compare to general prison and jail populations over the same period?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
ICE detainee deaths spiked in fiscal year 2025, with reporting showing at least 20–23 deaths and some outlets saying the year was the deadliest since 2004 [1] [2]. Available sources document a sharp rise in average detainee population — about 60,000 per month in 2025 — and note that higher population plus strained medical staffing are major drivers of more deaths, but none of the provided sources give a single, comparable mortality rate (deaths per 1,000 or 100,000) that directly compares ICE detention to the general prison or jail populations over the same period [3] [1] [2].
1. What the raw ICE numbers show and how reporters characterize the trend
Multiple outlets report an unusually large number of deaths in ICE custody in 2025. The American Immigration Council and El País record that 2025 was the deadliest year for ICE detainees in decades, with 21–23 deaths officially reported in the fiscal year and commentary calling it “the deadliest since 2004” [1] [2]. The Guardian and other outlets trace an upward trajectory beginning in 2024 and continuing into 2025 [4]. ICE’s own detainee-death reporting portal is cited as the agency’s method of tracking such deaths but the provided sources do not include a single consolidated mortality rate metric derived from ICE data [5] [6].
2. Why deaths rose: population growth, overcrowding and strained medical care
Reporting links the rise in deaths to a very large increase in the detained population — about 60,000 people on average per month in 2025 compared with 18,000–30,000 in prior years — and to overstretched medical and supervisory resources in the facilities [3]. Humanitarian groups and journalists cite staffing shortages, delayed or inappropriate medical treatment, and overcrowded conditions as proximate causes; the ACLU previously reported that medical failures contributed to the vast majority of past detainee deaths (88 percent diagnostic errors in one ACLU analysis) [7] [3] [8]. Advocates and local officials tie those operational failures to more preventable deaths in 2025 [3] [8].
3. What comparable prison/jail data is and what’s missing from these sources
The question asks for mortality rates that compare ICE detainees to general prison and jail populations over the same period. Available reporting here documents ICE death counts and detainee population size jumps but does not provide a standardized mortality rate for ICE custody or published, contemporaneous death-rate figures for state/federal prisons and local jails to permit a direct apples‑to‑apples comparison [1] [3] [5]. In short: these sources show rising ICE deaths and rising detained population but do not publish a comparative deaths-per-capita series covering prisons, jails, and ICE detention in 2024–2025 [1] [2] [5].
4. Conflicting narratives and official pushback
Media and advocacy outlets frame the spike as a systemic failure tied to policy and resource choices; the Independent records DHS pushback noting that the Biden administration had a higher death rate for a comparable six-month period in 2024 than the early 2025 period cited by some critics [9]. ICE and DHS have a formal reporting policy and publish press releases about individual deaths, which the agency says reflect its notification and review procedures [5] [6]. Both narratives are present in the sources: critics emphasize preventability and systemic neglect [8] [3]; officials emphasize process and context, including prior-period comparisons [9] [5].
5. What a rigorous comparison would require (and why it’s not yet in these reports)
A valid comparison requires: (a) a consistent denominator (average daily population) for each system (ICE, federal prisons, state prisons, local jails) over the same time window; (b) uniform definitions of “in‑custody death” (e.g., excluding deaths in hospitals versus inside facilities); (c) cause-of-death breakdowns (illness, suicide, homicide, accidental); and (d) independent review of reporting completeness. The sources provide ICE death counts and population snapshots for 2025 but do not supply contemporaneous, standardized mortality rates for prisons and jails or the uniform denominators needed to compute comparable rates [3] [5].
6. Bottom line and reporting limitations
Available reporting documents a clear spike in ICE custody deaths coinciding with a large increase in detainee numbers and chronic medical/staffing problems; human‑rights groups say many of those deaths were likely preventable [3] [8] [1]. However, the sources provided do not contain the normalized mortality rates for ICE and for the general prison and jail populations that would be required to state definitively whether ICE detainees were dying at a higher or lower rate than incarcerated people in other systems over the same period [1] [3] [5]. Further analysis would need official detention‑population denominators and prison/jail mortality statistics for the same fiscal years to produce a defensible comparison.