Has ICE captured and deported legal residents, visa holders and citizens
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Available reporting documents that ICE has arrested, detained and in some cases deported lawful residents, visa holders and even U.S. citizens during 2024–2025 enforcement surges. Investigations and watchdogs cite dozens to possibly tens of thousands affected in specific operations (for example, roughly 56,000 deportations during the 2025 government shutdown period reported by The Guardian) and at least 70 citizens confirmed deported in earlier GAO reporting plus dozens more wrongful detentions tallied by ProPublica and others [1] [2] [3].
1. What the public record shows: arrests, detentions and deportations across statuses
ICE and DHS data and independent reporting establish that enforcement actions in 2025 swept across populations: people without status, visa-holders, lawful permanent residents and cases involving U.S. citizens. The Guardian reported roughly 56,000 deportations over the shutdown window and said ICE arrested people “with legal status, including citizens” [1]. ICE’s own data breakdowns show arrests categorized by citizenship and criminal history, underscoring that many detainees had no criminal convictions [4] [5].
2. U.S. citizens: documented wrongful arrests, detentions and some deportations
Multiple watchdog reports and journalistic investigations document Americans detained by immigration agents. The Government Accountability Office found up to 70 U.S. citizens deported between 2015–2020 and ProPublica and other outlets have identified at least hundreds of citizen detentions since 2021, with specific cases from 2025 cited in national reporting [2] [3]. ProPublica compiled cases and NPR and local outlets have interviewed detained citizens, showing this is not merely anecdote [3] [6].
3. Visa-holders and lawful permanent residents: revocations, denials and deportations
Reporting shows F/M/J student visa cancellations and other visa revocations led to detentions and removals in 2025; The Guardian and BBC documented sudden cancellations and removals of students, and the State Department/administration-level policy moves include continuous vetting of millions of visa-holders that can trigger revocation and deportation when violations are alleged [7] [8] [9]. Lawful permanent residents (green card holders) have also been detained and transported in high-profile cases reported by The Conversation and legal observers [10].
4. Government denials vs. oversight findings: competing narratives
DHS and ICE publicly assert their operations are targeted and deny systemic deportation of citizens; DHS posted statements that “ICE does NOT arrest or deport U.S. citizens” and described safeguards and training [11]. Oversight bodies and Congressmembers, plus ProPublica and GAO findings, contradict that certainty: GAO identified citizen deportations in past years and members of Congress demanded investigations into citizen detentions in 2025 [2] [12]. The discrepancy likely stems from agency posture versus documented case-level errors and incomplete internal tracking [2] [11].
5. Scale and who bears the burden: enforcement priorities and real-world impact
ICE’s own categories show many detained people had no convictions and many detentions stem from civil immigration violations [4] [13]. NGOs and reporting (Vera, The Guardian, American Immigration Council) note large detention counts—tens of thousands in custody at times—and that a high share lack criminal convictions, which amplifies the risk that lawful residents and visa-holders will be swept up [5] [14] [1].
6. Causes identified in reporting: errors, databases, policy shifts and “continuous vetting”
Reporting highlights multiple drivers: misidentification and outdated records, policy shifts toward expansive arrests and revoking visas, new continuous vetting of millions of visa-holders, and reduced protections at so‑called “sensitive locations.” GAO and advocacy analyses point to inconsistent training and poor tracking that contribute to wrongful actions [2] [9] [14].
7. Legal framework and limits — and the practical gap
Federal law gives ICE broad authority to detain noncitizens; courts and experts stress constitutional limits and the role of immigration judges. But legal protections do not prevent mistaken detentions or the immediate consequences of detention and deportation when agency errors occur—cases documented by ProPublica, NPR, and others show citizens and lawful residents can still be held for days or removed in error [10] [3] [6].
8. What remains uncertain and what sources don’t say
Available sources document many cases and provide estimates, but they also show gaps: the government does not consistently track or publicly report a comprehensive count of U.S. citizens detained by immigration agents as of 2025, and agency databases and public tallies are incomplete [2] [14]. Specific nationwide totals for wrongful deportations since 2021 are not uniformly available in the cited reporting [2].
9. What watchdogs and lawmakers are demanding — and why it matters
Members of Congress and civil‑rights groups have demanded investigations, legislative protections and improved tracking after the documented cases and GAO findings; lawmakers argue systemic fixes are necessary to prevent future wrongful detentions and deportations [12] [15]. The policy debate juxtaposes DHS’s claim of targeted enforcement with persistent evidence of mistaken or excessive actions [11] [1].
Bottom line: reporting from mainstream outlets, watchdogs and federal reviews documents that ICE operations in 2024–2025 have ensnared lawful permanent residents, visa-holders and U.S. citizens in arrests, detentions and in some cases deportations; DHS disputes the scale but oversight findings and multiple case compilations make clear the problem is real and incompletely tracked [1] [2] [3].