What primary documents exist from 1980 about the eviction of Mary Filan and where can they be accessed?
This fact-check may be outdated. Consider refreshing it to get the most current information.
Executive summary
Contemporary primary-source reporting about the 1980 eviction of Mary Filan is thin but concrete: the original Village Voice story (May 5, 1980) and a documented follow‑up (reported as May 12, 1980) are the principal contemporaneous journalistic records; a May 1980 Newsday photograph tied to the incident is also cited in modern compilations [1] [2] [3]. Searches of major newspaper databases turned up no broad press corps chain of coverage beyond the Voice and the photographed evidence, a gap that independent fact‑checks have flagged [2].
1. The Village Voice original report — the primary contemporary article and where to read it
The lead primary document is Joe Conason’s Village Voice piece published in early May 1980, headlined in archives and later repostings as “Trump Evicts Stroke Victim, 74” (the Voice’s May 5, 1980 reporting is repeatedly cited by secondary sources) and that article describes the April 25, 1980 eviction, naming the tenant, apartment address, the city marshal Norman Katz, and the Trump Organization as the landlord responsible for the eviction [1] [4]. The Village Voice archive pages and reproduction posts (including the Voice’s archived repost and staging pages) are the direct access points for that article today [4]; several contemporary reprints and retrospectives republish or quote the Voice story [5] [6].
2. The Voice follow‑up and contemporary reportage — limited but documented
A follow‑up story published about a week after the initial Voice piece is referenced in later fact‑checks and histories: Conason’s May 12, 1980 follow‑up reportedly records a Trump Organization official visiting Filan in hospital and offering alternative housing, and fact‑checkers note that this second Voice piece exists even though other mainstream outlets of the time did not amplify it [2] [1]. The existence of that follow‑up is treated as a continuation of the primary contemporary record and is accessible the same way as the original Voice item through the Voice archives and reproductions [2] [4].
3. Photographic evidence — the Newsday photo cited online
A May 1980 Newsday photograph showing Mary Filan after the eviction is cited by later online memorials and compilations and appears in reproduced press collections; Find a Grave and image reposts identify a Newsday photo from May 1980 tied to Filan’s eviction [3]. The primary source for that photo would be Newsday’s own archives or microfilm collections of the newspaper; online secondary hosts reproduce and cite the Newsday image but the original Newsday archive is the authoritative source [3].
4. Official eviction paperwork and court records — absence from available reporting
Contemporary news accounts name City Marshal Norman Katz as executing the eviction and describe an eviction notice taped to Filan’s door, but the provided reporting does not produce digital copies of the marshal’s writ, the underlying landlord‑tenant court judgment, or marshal service records [1] [5]. Searches of aggregated newspaper databases by later fact‑checkers reportedly found no additional 1980 press coverage beyond the Voice and the photo, and the sources warn that direct court or marshal documents are not reproduced in the accessible reporting [2]. Therefore, while the marshal and eviction notice are described in the Voice article, the actual court-filed eviction order and marshal docket are not available through the provided sources and would require archival retrieval from New York City or Queens County court/marshal records [1] [2].
5. How to access the primary documents cited in modern accounts
For immediate access to what is documented in contemporary reporting, consult the Village Voice archive reproductions and staging pages that host the May 5 and May 12, 1980 articles (the Voice archival reposts are cited in modern summaries) and search Newsday’s 1980 archives or microfilm collections for the May 1980 photograph credited in later compilations [4] [3]. Independent fact‑checking sites that reviewed the case (Snopes) summarize these primary items and their limits and note the lack of broader contemporary press corroboration [2]. For missing official records (marshal docket, eviction writ, landlord court file), researchers would need to petition Queens County civil court archives or the office that holds city marshal execution records; those official sources are not reproduced in the supplied reporting and therefore cannot be linked to or cited here [2].
6. What remains uncertain and where further primary evidence likely lives
Contemporary Village Voice reporting and a Newsday photo form the backbone of the primary record available in online retrospectives, but the absence of court filings, a clear chain of TV news clips, or multiple contemporaneous mainstream newspaper stories is acknowledged by later fact‑checks and historians; those omissions mean that definitive official paperwork is not visible in the provided sources and must be sought in physical court or newspaper archives [2] [3]. Modern reproductions and remembrances reliably point back to the Voice pieces as the primary journalistic evidence from 1980 [1] [4].